Copying Is Not Theft - Official Version

Channel:Question Copyright · Length:1:00 · Published:2010-04-02 · Views:916771

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Nina Paley's one-minute animated free culture anthem with vocals by Connie Champagne, arguing that copying is not theft.

Why HN recommends it

Linked constantly in copyright and piracy debates as a short explainer of the difference between copying and physical theft.

A one minute ELI5 explanation about the difference between physical and intellectual property. — HN, 2022

Hacker culture & free software · Law, policing & justice · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] coping is not stealing a thing leaves one less left copying it makes one thing more that's what copying for copying is not them if I copy yours you have it too one for me and one for you that's what copies can do if I steal your bicycle you have to take a bus but if I just copy it there's one for each of us making more of a thing that is what we call copying sharing ideas with everyone that's why copying is fun [Music]

On Hacker News

When this video* was published, I thought the idea it tells was too obvious and well known, but time proved me wrong it seems. Please watch it. (*) [VIDEO] — vibragiel, 2010-12
Which dictionary defines taking as simply gaining or acquiring something? If you "take" something from someone else it generally means that they no longer have what you took. This is all really pretty simple: [VIDEO] Also, (at least in the US) legally copyright infringement is distinct from stealing. — autoexec, 2023-12
It’s been more than a decade since I had the opportunity to plug this educative video in an internet conversation: [VIDEO] — glerk, 2022-04
Oh no, you are now required to watch this damned cartoon: [VIDEO] (A one minute ELI5 explanation about the difference between physical and intellectual property.) — Matumio, 2022-01
I can't believe people are still equating copyright infringement with physical theft. Didn't that tired old argument die a long time ago ? If not, why not ? One more time, boys and girls: [VIDEO] — jra_samba, 2016-10

Related videos