Conventional Keyboards Are STAGGERINGLY STUPID!

Channel:Ben Vallack · Length:6:39 · Published:2020-05-30 · Views:209784

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ben Vallack compares finger movement on a staggered keyboard with an ortholinear grid keyboard, using an Anne Pro 2 and a ZSA Planck EZ. He argues the stagger forces awkward finger motion.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it in keyboard threads as a short visual demonstration of why staggered layouts force unnatural finger movement.

These videos [2][3] from Ben Vallack demonstrate this nicely. — HN, 2021

Consumer devices & gadgets · Product & industrial design

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] [Applause] [Music] so got to keyboards here one is a forty-percent author linear keyboard and this one there's a 60% normal layout with the staggered rows so I'm comparing author linear with the staggered keyboards the kind of main question is is it worth relearning your muscle memory because obviously we've all kind of grown up with staggered keyboards for most of us can type on those is it worth reprogramming your mind and you want your muscles to use Auto linear is the benefit worth that investment of your your effort so that's all we're gonna find out in this video obviously the author linear one I'm looking at has a 40 percent board so it's slightly smaller than 60 percent staggered worth but the principles I'm looking at here only apply to the actual letter keys anyway so we can compare them fairly and I actually think there's a really obvious winner and hopefully the video will make that clear so before we get stuck and I just want to mention this channel it's obviously very new channel there are very few subscribers yeah hopefully that's gonna change with these videos so the idea with this channel is I'm gonna make videos covering design usability and workflow so all those kind of productivity stuff looking at products

On Hacker News

Note that on normal keyboard all alpha keys are staggered to the left. For both hands. So, this stagger is not helping you to keep your left hand at correct angle. "Grid" ortholinear is not an ultimate solution either, but it is more comfy (from personal experience). There is a short video about ortho vs stagger [VIDEO] — Fetiorin, 2022-08
Where are all the 75% ortholinear split keyboards? All the super-duper ergo boards have very few keys and/or a strange layout (like this Djinn). Currently the best keyboard for my left forearm's RSI has been Mistel Barocco MD770 [1] but I've recently been aware how the staggering maybe forces the fingers to travel in slightly unnatural ways. These videos [2][3] from Ben Vallack demonstrate this n… — h3mb3, 2021-11
This is simply not true. [VIDEO] With ortholinear this argument holds more without actually twisting your wrists. — devenvdev, 2021-02

Related videos