Passengers, Rearranged

Channel:Nerdwriter1 · Length:8:49 · Published:2017-04-19 · Views:6248511

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Nerdwriter1 shows how rearranging the scenes of the film Passengers, so the audience shares the female lead's confusion, would change the movie. It draws on discussion of the original script.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it to illustrate how simply reordering scenes can transform a story.

NerdWriter on youtube has a good video on how the change would look — HN, 2021

Film analysis & criticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

Here's a question for aspiring screenwriters: Is it possible to make the movie "Passengers" better with some relatively minor changes? You know, I don't think this is a really bad film. After hearing reviews from friends and online, I sort of expected it to be. But I think that feeling was mostly disappointed expectation. Passengers is by no means a train wreck. It's just really, really predictable. The plot goes like this: After the interstellar spaceship, Avalon, malfunctions, Chris Pratt wakes up from hyper sleep ninety years before he's supposed to. Ninety years before anyone else on the ship. He can't go back to sleep. He can't contact earth. He can't get to the ship's controls. He tries to do all of these things and fails. As a year passes, he grows increasingly sad and hopeless. So eventually he decides to wake up another passenger, Jennifer Lawrence, condemning her to the same fate, essentially death. In order to give himself some more company. He acts like it's another malfunction. He doesn't tell her. After a while, they fall in love. She finds out the truth, gets really mad, and then the ship begins to really malfunction. So Pratt sacrifices himself to save it, but in the end, she saves him.

On Hacker News

Yeah but it wouldn't have been tempered by growing attached to Pratt's character and we would get to experience the same feeling of confusion as JLaw's character. NerdWriter on youtube has a good video on how the change would look, does a better job of selling it than I ever could: [VIDEO] — rtkwe, 2021-06
A good example of the rearranging is from Nerdwriters YouTube [VIDEO] Just a minor change in order of the same scenes completely changed a movie. — aequitas, 2018-03
It would be interesting to watch an edit played in chronological order. A similar response was made to Passengers[1], where if it is NOT made chronologically, the director could have an opportunity to push the theme entirely close to a horror genre. 1. [VIDEO] — clarkdale, 2022-12
The movie could have been great if it was oriented around the female passenger waking up and not knowing what had already happened before instead of the audience knowing everything linearly [VIDEO] — joshuahedlund, 2021-06

Related videos