"Two incompatible sacred values in American universities" Jon Haidt, Hayek Lecture Series

Channel:Duke University Department of Political Science · Length:1:06:23 · Published:2016-10-15 · Views:772687

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jonathan Haidt's Hayek Lecture at Duke argues American universities pursue two potentially incompatible sacred values, truth and social justice. He discusses campus conflict, honor, dignity and victimhood cultures, and viewpoint diversity.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it heavily in diversity and academia debates as an intellectual analysis of the truth versus social justice conflict.

This is the best intellectual analysis of the situation I've come across so far — HN, 2018

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Social issues & culture · Psychology & human behavior

Subtitles (excerpt)

well thanks so much Bruce and thanks to all of you for that warm warm welcome so 2016 is a very very strange year it feels very strange around the world extraordinary violence in Syria and Iraq driving political events in Europe novel events the likes of which nobody expected of course in the United States our political season is producing something that nobody ever expected many people on both right and left feel that the apocalypse is coming if the other side wins in fact things are so bad that many people around the country are going to be writing in third party candidates such as giant meteor now it's a very strange time for Humanity but it is a wonderful time to be studying moral psychology because all of these conflicts all of this division this is all driven mostly driven by people who think that they are pursuing the good they are fighting what they think is the good fight moral psychology can help explain almost all the conflicts I would say all the conflicts that we are having around the world and around the country in other talks I apply moral psychology to the American situation but today what I want to do here here with you at Duke is to apply it to the University this is the institution that we are in extraordinary turmoil began

On Hacker News

I'm glad you posted this.. I had heard about anti CoC a while back(perhaps from you?) but never really dug into it.. Video game journalism was ruined for me back in 2011 and 2012 for reasons we all know and I was hyper aware of at the time. It went through a very dark time and is hopefully coming out the other side now.. I had not really paid much attention to the infiltration of the tech communi… — Rapzid, 2018-05
Somewhat related to the issue at hand and representative of the current, very charged landscape on social issues, is this video: [VIDEO] The speaker makes the case that current social conflicts at many American universities – though probably representative of the general population as well – arise because people are pursuing two, potentially incompatible goals: truth and social justice. I think i… — plainOldText, 2017-08
Jonathan Haidt does a great job explaining Honor, Dignity, and Victimhood cultures: [VIDEO] (whole talk is excellent) His take is a little different (that Victimhood culture is a result of a march through time from Honor to Dignity to Victimhood). He's referencing the same paper [1] mentioned in the reason.com article. [1] - Microaggression and Moral Cultures [LINK] — mparr4, 2017-08
>I've found that lots of people out there seemingly can't handle disagreement at all... This is the second time this week I'll have linked this here on HN but I'm exceptionally happy to do so. Jonathan Haidt has a topical discussion[1] about that and hypothesizes it stems from an utter lack of viewpoint diversity as kids grow up. He states that universities have sought to remove all emotional dis… — Rayhem, 2022-12
Jon Haidt talks about it for a while. [VIDEO] I would recommend the book: The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas Are Setting Up a Generation for Failure [LINK] — ternaus, 2020-07

Related videos