Try this bizarre audio illusion! 👁️👂😮 - BBC

Channel:BBC · Length:3:25 · Published:2010-11-10 · Views:5767467

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A BBC Horizon clip demonstrating the McGurk effect, where the same audio sounds like different syllables depending on the mouth movements you see. It shows that people integrate visual speech information into what they hear.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the standard demonstration that the brain reinterprets perception, in threads on speech, AI audio and illusions.

The most compelling illustration I've seen of this is the McGurk Affect[1]. — HN, 2012

Neuroscience & the brain · Magic, puzzles & curiosities · Language & linguistics

Subtitles (excerpt)

At any one moment. We are being bombarded by sensory information Our brains do a remarkable job of making sense of it all It seems easy enough to separate the sounds we hear from the sights we see but there is one illusion that reveals this isn't always the case Have a look at this ah what do you hear ba ba, Ba? But look what happens when we change the picture and yet, the sound hasn't changed in Every clip you are only ever hearing ba with a b it's an illusion known as the mcGurk effect Ba take another look Concentrate first on the right of the screen now to the left of the screen The illusion occurs because what you are seeing clashes with what you are hearing. In the illusion, what we see overrides what we hear so the mouth movements We see as we look at a face can actually influence what we believe we're hearing if we close our eyes We actually hear the sound as it is if we open our eyes. We actually see how the mouth movements can influence what we're hearing It's a bizarre effect Remember the only sound you're hearing is ba with a b what's remarkable about this illusion is even knowing how it's done Doesn't seem to make a difference The effect works no matter how much you know about the

On Hacker News

If you like this sort of thing, and haven't heard of the McGurk Effect before, take a look at this: [VIDEO] . — kkylin, 2017-08
"People already lie to themselves" The most compelling illustration I've seen of this is the McGurk Affect[1]. [1] [VIDEO] — lunarscape, 2012-07
It was people clapping in mission control but your brain wants to think the sound matches the images so your brain tricks you into thinking it is the sound of water splashing. This is sometimes known as the McGurk effect [VIDEO] — barbegal, 2020-08
>For some reason I can easily understand people on video chat even if they have strong accent whereas I can't grok anything on a phone call. See the McGurk Effect: [VIDEO] — jml7c5, 2019-06
Are you talking about the McGurk effect? You hear either Ba or Fa depending on which you expect to hear based on the lip reading (but the sound that is actually playing is Va): [VIDEO] It is really cool that small contextual information can change our senses so dramatically without us being aware of it happening. — zawerf, 2018-05

Related videos