Donald B. Gillies Lecture: Dr. Michael Stonebraker

Channel:Siebel School of Computing and Data Science · Length:1:05:45 · Published:2018-04-09 · Views:13920

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Turing Award winner Michael Stonebraker gives the 2018 Donald B. Gillies Memorial Lecture at Illinois. He discusses the gap between academic research and industry problems, publishing incentives, and the influence of large industry users on research.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in many threads about academic incentives, paper counts and why academia struggles to produce working software.

There's a lot more, I highly recommend the talk! — HN, 2024

Databases & storage · Tech pioneers & interviews · University lectures & courses

Subtitles (excerpt)

Memorial Lecture today this lectureship was established at the University of Illinois through memorial gifts by family and friends with a major contribution by the the Digital Equipment Corporation okay so so I'm Donald B Gillis memorial lecturer today is Mike is one of the founding members of the field of database systems he's currently a faculty member at MIT after having had spent many years at UC Berkeley Mike built one of the first database systems that is built on top of the relational model called ingress in the 1970s building on top of a theoretical paper by Edgar F Codd who was another Turing Award winner since then mike has revolutionized the database research what database research and database industry time and time again with a number of influential database systems Postgres C store eight store Sai DB and so on and he's still active and he's still going strong Mike is the recipient of the 2015 Turing award which is a greatest honor given to computer scientists he was the Sigma or Edgar F guard innovations Award winner in 1992 and the I Triple E John von Neumann Neumann award in winner in 2005 most importantly Mike is known to be refreshingly candid in his viewpoints so I have no doubt that today's talk will both delight and entertain all of you

On Hacker News

Yes, this is a development that has happened over time and has become pretty severe. Michael Stonebraker has written/talked about this in the context of DBMS research, but to me the same issues are applicable to other fields as well. Slides: [LINK] Talk: [VIDEO] In short, the incentives/requirements in academia have changed so that producing working software is no longer feasible. He says he got … — mpweiher, 2024-04
I often go back to this talk from Michael Stonebraker about, in his terms, the diarrhea of papers [1]. It's difficult to justify time towards anything that doesn't lead to a near-term publication or another line on your CV. [1] [VIDEO] — psychomugs, 2021-05
> academia’s ideal role is to simply advance human understanding in interesting ways Yes and no. This is an engineering science. In a pure science, the world is out there to explore and find out about, constraining what you do. An engineering science is very much about useful things we can build and how we can get better at doing that. Buildings that stay up and house people/things, planes that c… — mpweiher, 2018-09
> I often fall into the thinking of top 10 or 20 appstore app terms You're not the only one. As far as I can tell, the vast majority of (particularly, but not exclusively) compiler work is driven by these edge cases. As an example, when I look a the justifications for pushing undefined behavior exploitation in C, invariably some Very Smart Compiler Guy™ will state with great authority that this i… — mpweiher, 2023-06
It goes beyond grants and extrinsic motivation...well maybe the latter category is pretty much all-encompassing. Turing Award winner Michael Stonebraker talked about this at length here: [VIDEO] Some points: - Original (risky) research is detrimental and likely fatal to a career in science - Actually creating systems doubly so — mpweiher, 2022-07

Related videos