Why our generals were more successful in World War II than in Korea, Vietnam or Iraq/Afghanistan

Channel:UC Berkeley Events · Length:58:49 · Published:2011-03-23 · Views:2199681

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Thomas Ricks's Nimitz Memorial Lecture at UC Berkeley asks why US generals did better in World War II than in Korea, Vietnam or Iraq and Afghanistan. A central point is the WWII practice of quickly reassigning or relieving underperforming generals.

Why HN recommends it

Used in hiring and management debates as an analysis of fast evaluation, quick dismissal without stigma, and the cost of keeping underperformers.

Possibly the best analysis of this I have yet seen is the video — HN, 2021

Management, leadership & organizations · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

well good evening welcome to the 27th annual nimit Lector ship thank you so much for coming tonight my name is Captain Phil Rose I am the director of military Affairs here at Cal and uh also the commanding officer of the naval RC unit it's the best job in the Navy uh the Nimitz lecture series was established by endowment to invite prominent speakers to lecture and educate not only our students but also our community on items of national interest and relevance since the establishment of the program in 1983 we've hosted a wide array of distinguished and nationally recognized public figures who have enriched us with their unique perspectives and expertise on an equally wide array of topics ladies and gentlemen we have all have an obligation to be an informed public and uh I'm honored that you have come tonight it's an honor and a privilege to welcome Mr Tom Ricks as our 27th Nimitz lecturer Mr Rick Hail To Us um from Massachusetts originally and has an extensive personal and professional background perfectly suited for this venue he grew up in New York also spent time as a student in the American International School in cabul graduated from Yale and after teaching in Hong Kong for two years and serving as an assistant editor with the Wilson quarterly

On Hacker News

Possibly the best analysis of this I have yet seen is the video Why our generals were most successful in World War II that in Korea, Vietnam or Iraq/Afghanistan: [VIDEO] Essentially, the answer is the hiring methodology. If someone seemed like a best fit for a job then they were hired. They then had two weeks to demonstrate basic functional capacity and six weeks to make significant progress. If … — m0llusk, 2021-11
This is a interesting talk held on UC Berkeley about the culture of firing officers during WWII: [VIDEO] Thomas E. Ricks main hypothesis is that the US failures in Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq can be attributed to the culture of firing under-performing disappearing. It mirrors what I've seen in a lot of organizations as well, under-performing executives keeping their jobs when they shouldn't. — sofrimiento, 2024-03
Never joke about firing people, but don't hesitate to do it. That is the complete advice. Joking about firing people never brought anything good; firing people when needed, that is essential for organizations. There is a lengthy explanation in this: "Why our generals were more successful in World War II than in Korea, Vietnam or Iraq/Afghanistan" ( [VIDEO] ) — AdrianB1, 2020-06
A potentially interesting contrast: Why our generals were more successful in WWII than in Korea, Vietnam, or Iraq/Afghanistan [VIDEO] Briefly, minimize the application process and aggressively review work. Any mistake or failure and you're fired, two weeks to prove competence or you're fired, six weeks until a significant accomplishment or you're fired. And no stigma against being fired, just kee… — m0llusk, 2022-12
This reminds me of this historian's theory that WWII generals were unusually successful because of the dynamic way they were assigned and potentially reassigned within weeks: (US Berkeley Events 2011) [VIDEO] — m0llusk, 2021-08

Related videos