Joe Rogan Experience #1191 - Peter Boghossian & James Lindsay

Channel:PowerfulJRE · Length:1:58:37 · Published:2018-10-30 · Views:2506442

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Joe Rogan interviews Peter Boghossian and James Lindsay, who describe their hoax papers submitted to academic journals in grievance studies. The conversation runs about two hours and covers academic publishing, ideology and victimhood culture.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as an entertaining account of how easily fake papers get published and of problems in academic peer review.

If you have not watched Peter Boghossian and James Lindsay on the Joe Rogan show you should. — HN, 2019

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Social issues & culture · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

even here there breathing it's a sensitive it's a good stuff live already damn there's no countdown Jamie your radical your radical mr. Bogosian welcome back good thanks good to be here thank mr. Lindsey good the James or Jim depending upon preferences that's right go with Jim Jeff first of all gentlemen and there was one other person that you did this with this whole project helen pluck rose from england shout out to helen from england thanks she back across the pond she's across the pond she's fish and chips and she's making tea and managing here we go magazine right excellent all right well shout out to her as well let's explain what you guys did and what's so significant about it because when I first read it my first inclination I had two reactions one was a huge laugh I laughed really hard and then I said thank God somebody exposed this you know yeah so tell me tell me which guys the gym go for it yeah so over it let's explain who you guys are what okay okay um my background is in mathematics I bailed out on academia in 2010 though because I kind of see the writing on the wall and so now I am a renegade gender scholar and I write nonsense about genitals that's primarily what I do I mean I manage a business at home so I got

On Hacker News

If you have not watched Peter Boghossian and James Lindsay on the Joe Rogan show you should. Very entertaining and shows how ridiculous these publications are. [VIDEO] — geomark, 2019-11
The term "competitive victimhood" came to my attention after watching the Joe Rogan interview of Peter Boghossian and James Lindsay who pranked academic journals with research papers based on ridiculous premises. A must watch IMO [VIDEO] — geomark, 2019-02
> But does that justify what they did? Yes, it does. These journals are an absolute joke, make a mockery of any serious attempt to advance knowledge and understanding, and deserve to be pilloried. Their standards of rigour and review are shockingly poor and as such they do not provide a suitable vehicle for the publication of genuine research, or for measured consideration of the content they do … — bartread, 2019-02
> Absolutely terrifying. Indeed. We seem to be increasingly awash with evidence that the standards of rigour in academic journals across a number of fields are... quite poor. Peter Boghossian, James Lindsay and Helen Pluckrose set out to demonstrate this in the field of grievance studies by submitting and, in some cases, successfully publishing a series of fake papers: [VIDEO] I mean, in some sen… — bartread, 2019-04
It's a 3 page document that makes a number of false assumptions. They extrapolate bitcoin to having 300 billion transactions and means no lightening or L2 solution and the block size would be 3gigs. Nor do they even factor in the halving. Wasn't even researched properly, just utter nonsense for the papers. And Joe Rogan was showing how easy it is to publish fake papers in journals. [VIDEO] here i… — Cypher, 2018-11

Related videos