LESSON 1: Do Not Obey In Advance

Channel:Timothy Snyder · Length:7:39 · Published:2021-09-28 · Views:133896

Watch on YouTube

Summary

The first lesson from Timothy Snyder's short video series accompanying On Tyranny, arguing that most of the power of authoritarianism is freely given when people comply in advance. It runs about eight minutes.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in political threads as a short, accessible companion to Snyder's book and as a reminder not to obey in advance.

I also recommend the short Youtube series Snyder recorded before the release of the graphic edition — HN, 2025

US politics & elections · World history · Politics & history (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Applause] [Music] i'm timothy snyder i'm a historian i've written some books a couple of years ago about three and a half years ago i did a little series called timothy snyder speaks a few very short informal videos low production values mostly about contemporary politics people still seem to be watching these and asking me whether i can do some more so that is what i'm going to do now now is the summer of 2021 and so what i'm going to be speaking about the occasion for this new series is the the new edition of my little political pamphlet on tyranny so my little book on tyranny was published in early 2017. as i didn't expect it was then read and translated around the world used in demonstrations around the world read in parliaments around the world that served as the basis for art and for all kinds of other forms of expression i i wasn't surprised that it became useful in the united states i was a little surprised at perhaps how useful what i'm going to do today and in the 20 little segments to come is to return to the book and there's a specific reason why i'm doing this we are now four years on we're now in a new political moment i've revised some of the text of the book not the lessons themselves they're entirely unchanged but i've

On Hacker News

Could not agree more! I also recommend the short Youtube series Snyder recorded before the release of the graphic edition: Lesson 1: [VIDEO] Full Playlist: [LINK] — neo4llm, 2025-03
He has a new book On Freedom , too. I haven't read it yet, but I have watched him give excellent talks on youtube, which reference it. I believe his core thesis in On Freedom is that America has focused on negative freedom, when what really matters is positive freedom. "Negative freedom" is the idea that no government should interfere with your life. Authoritarian regimes arbitrarily exercise pow… — hayst4ck, 2025-03
I would go spend a couple of days on Yale history professor Timothy Snyder reading his books and then watch him on YouTube. Harvard law professor Lawrence Lessig is also a major academic in this area. Their respective relevant books are "The Road to Unfreedom" and "They Don't Represent Us." Timothy Snyder also wrote "On Tyranny," which is a very quick read which is directly applicable to the ques… — hayst4ck, 2023-04
My bad. Doesn't look like I can delete my submission. I apologize for coming off gotcha, gloaty, or sneering I thought I was being pretty blunt. I was genuinely surprised yesterday and realized I have a huge misunderstanding about how things operate here. On the Elon thread dang stated that users flag articles and implied that user flagging was the overriding arbiter of authority on HN and linked… — _DeadFred_, 2025-01
Gutless. That's how it happens in authoritarian regimes. People start obeying in advance. Do not obey in advance: [VIDEO] — peutetre, 2024-12

Related videos