Alan Kay on Dijkstra

Channel:vermilyer · Length:2:38 · Published:2011-06-07 · Views:19654

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Alan Kay commenting on Edsger Dijkstra in a humorous, pointed way.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it as a joke in threads about Dijkstra's writings, not as a recommendation.

Software (other) · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

the other thing I want to do in the beginning part of this talk uh I tried to figure out how to work my way into it and I finally remembered the uh paper that dyra I don't know how many of you have ever met dyra but you probably know that arrogance in computer science is measured in N Nano dyras and he once wrote a a paper of the kind that he liked to write a lot of uh which had the title on the fact that the Atlantic has two sides and it was basically all about how different the approaches to Computing science were uh in Europe especially in in Holland and uh and in the United States and there many interesting you know in the US here we were not mathematical enough and um gee in in Holland if you're a full Professor you're actually appointed by the queen and there are many other uh important distinctions made between the the two cultures so um I wrote a rebuttal paper is called on the fact that most of the software in the world is written on one side of the [Applause] Atlantic and it was basically about because I had a math degree too was basically about that computers form a new kind of math you can't judge them they don't really fit well into classical math and people who try to do that

On Hacker News

For better or worst, reading Dijkstra always reminds of these funny (I think) comments that Alan Kay made in 1997... "Arrogance in Computer Science is measured in nano-Dijkstras" --Alan Kay Video: [VIDEO] — dshep, 2020-09
"Arrogance in computer science is measured in nano-Dijkstra's" - Alan Kay ( [VIDEO] ) (I usually like Dijkstra's works but the quote does make a person smile.) — jimhefferon, 2020-07
Not advocating Alan Kay's view on Dijkstra here, but his answer to this is still very funny: [VIDEO] "You may know that arrogance in computer science is measured in Nano-Dijkstras. [..] I wrote a rebuttal paper just named 'On the fact that most software in the world is written on one side of the Atlantic'." — elcapitan, 2016-01

Related videos