"What UNIX Cost Us" - Benno Rice (LCA 2020)

Channel:linux.conf.au · Length:34:14 · Published:2020-01-15 · Views:218143

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Benno Rice's linux.conf.au 2020 talk asks whether UNIX was the best design we could have had. He looks at what alternatives existed, what was gained and lost, and what could be re-learned, including the limits of treating everything as a file.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an insightful and entertaining critique of UNIX design choices such as file descriptors and 'everything is a file'.

Benno Rice is an insightful, energetic, witty, and just plain enjoyable tech speaker. — HN, 2024

Operating systems & kernels · Linux & open-source ecosystems

Subtitles (excerpt)

welcome bin our rice so yeah after last year I thought I'd go a bit less controversial anyway so I thought I'd start in in good form by stealing something from Gary Bernard Gary Bernard is the author of the black talk if you haven't seen that see that then watch Katie's talk about explaining the wets but at the keynote that he gave at PyCon in Montreal few years back he talked about the state of knowing things but also the state of knowing that you know them and he put up this kind of truth table thing about whether you know something whether you met her know it and you know if you if you know it if you know something you know then you know it then it's a no not-it's knowledge it's it's it's there a saying you can use if it's saying you don't know but you know that you don't know it that's a known unknown that's something if you can go and find out later if you need to that's all good if you don't know it and you don't know that you don't know it then it's an unknown unknown in that saying that might come to bite you later on but there's a row missing from this what happens if you know something but you don't know that you know it Guerry to find that his ideology and I think that's a pretty good definition but on

On Hacker News

> for instance, Linux handles network socket, special files (like /proc/cpuinfo) or even USB devices as files. This is a powerful idea that can make easy to write or use programs for linux since we can rely in a set of well known operations from this abstraction called file. Benno Rice gave a fantastic talk a few years ago called "What UNIX Cost Us," which he starts off by showing how to write so… — favorited, 2025-03
I'll second this recommendation! Benno Rice is an insightful, energetic, witty, and just plain enjoyable tech speaker. 'What UNIX Cost Us'[1] is another favorite of mine that the audience on this post might enjoy: [VIDEO] — pxc, 2024-08
Not the author but I recommend: "What UNIX cost us" by Benno Rice: [VIDEO] In fact, this video argues that file descriptors are not as good as the author claims in their opening paragraph. They are another runaway idiosyncrasy borne out of the "everything is a file (but not really)" philosophy that underpins Linux. — sph, 2023-12
> I get that in abstract improvements "could" trickle down from that but once again without any performance benchmarks that is the definition of speculation. Fair enough, I am not sure whether CPU schedulers are shared across architectures, I am also not aware of any recent benchmarks other than: [LINK] Where I was going with my original statement/post is that I wouldn't be surprised to see Linux… — throwaway1194, 2024-07
Even PowerShell's flawed and limited execution definitively proves how terribly misguided and morally bankrupt the pin-headed one-dimensional "everything is a file" Unix philosophy is, especially with its the ridiculously hard-to-parse ad-hoc non-standard mixed-bag syntax of /proc and /etc files, which would have been much better simply using xml or json, yet which don't even come close to achiev… — DonHopkins, 2024-01

Related videos