You Can Win the Presidency With 22% of the Vote

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:6:31 · Published:2011-11-07 · Views:8492961

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short CGP Grey animation showing how the US electoral college lets a candidate win the presidency with as little as about 22 percent of the popular vote. It lays out the arithmetic of winning states by narrow margins.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in electoral-system discussions as a quick, clear argument against the electoral college.

you can effectively become president if you can get the right 22% of the USA to vote for you. — HN, 2016

Probability & game theory · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

In a fair democracy everyone's vote should count equally, but the method that the United States uses to elect its president, called the electoral college, violates this principle by making sure that some people's votes are more equal than others. The Electoral College is, essentially, the 538 votes that determine who wins the presidency. If these votes were split evenly across the population every 574,000 people would be represented by one vote. But that's not what happens because the Electoral College doesn't give votes to people, only states. Which has some unfair consequences. For example there are 11,500,000 people in Ohio so, to fairly represent them, it should get 20 electoral votes. But the Electoral college doesn't give Ohio 20 votes, it only gets 18 -- two less than it should. Where'd those other votes go? To states like Rhode Island. Plucky Rhode Island has 1.1 million people in it, so it should have about two votes, but instead it gets four! Those extra two votes that should be representing Ohioans go to representing Rhode Islanders instead? Why? Because, according to the rules of the electoral college, every state, no matter how few people live there, gets three votes to start with before the rest are distributed according

On Hacker News

>The electoral college is a form of protection for the naturally less densely populated agrarian states against the densely populated urban ones. This is commonly repeated, but it's BS. What "protection" does the electoral college give to Kansas, Wyoming, the Dakotas, Idaho, or Montana? Presidential candidates don't pay any attention to any of those "less densely populated agrarian states". In ad… — nanny, 2020-11
> It's been around for a couple of hundred years so it can't be that terrible. Heh. If only everything that is old was good. The all-or-nothing electoral college system: 1. Removes power from all people, because they vote for electors not for the actual candidates. 2. Removes representation of people in both swing and predetermined states, because they don't get represented by their elector (all … — cyphar, 2016-10
Some reasons why you shouldn't anymore (CGP Grey): [LINK] [VIDEO] Even in the UK, where the concept originates, a lot of people view it as a bad idea. The issue right now is that nobody can agree what to change it to, since people gravitate towards the voting system that helps them in the next election cycle (and the big two want it to remain a two-party system). — Someone1234, 2015-09
But the system (regardless of if you call it "points" or "an actual vote") means that one candidate could get 78% of the popular vote and still loose as discussed in [VIDEO] (it talks about how it's possible to win the electoral college with only 22% of the popular vote). I don't think that can be called a fair "actual vote". — SahAssar, 2019-12
>If presidential elections were just driven by popular vote candidates would only campaign in the top population centers. Entire regions of the country would be ignored. This is definitely 100% false; this goes against the mathematical population distribution of the United States. The top 100 biggest cities in the United States combined only make up less than 20% of the population. But even if it… — astura, 2019-04

Related videos