2017 ACM PPoPP Keynote: It's Time for a New Old Language
Channel:Guy Steele · Length:1:12:12 · Published:2017-05-19 · Views:6830
Summary
Guy Steele's PPoPP 2017 keynote surveying the history of computer science metanotation, including BNF, inference rules, and overline notation. He argues the field's notations are inconsistent and fragmented.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as an excellent talk on notation problems, useful when reading papers or designing a new metalanguage.
an excellent talk by Guy Steele that goes over issue of notation and balkanization — HN, 2020
Programming language design · Logic & formal methods · Tech pioneers & interviews
Subtitles (excerpt)
Is the sound okay? Yes. Much better. Okay. Sorting out all this technology takes time. All righty. Uh I'd like to begin this talk with an digression. Uh we had to fiddle with the technology because these slides have a strange aspect ratio. Uh if my slides are 4 to 3 but these projectors 16 to 9 I waste 25% of the screen. If my slides are 16 to 9 but projectors 4 to 3 I waste 25%. Uh so these slides are actually 20 to 13. And uh our technician seems to have made them very nicely match the screen. I think it looks pretty good. So a hand for the audio guy. The optimal comprised ratio is 8 to 3 root 3 and if you take continued fraction and then truncate it you get nice integer ratios. 20 to 13 is accurate within 1% and it wastes less than 13 and 1/2% of the screen whichever projector you run up against. Okay, but I'm really here to talk about the most popular programming language in computer science. The most popular programming language in computer science has no interpreter or compiler. Its definition is not written down in any one place. It's changed a lot over the decades and those changes have introduced some ambiguities and inconsistencies. We're going to take a look at that. Today dozens of variations are in use and the complexity of this language has reached
On Hacker News
You might be interested in Guy Steele’s talk “It’s time for a new old language”. He talks about similar notations and the problem of inventing new ones (although most of his talk is about things other than BNF-like notations : he just talks about them for a bit in the beginning). It’s an interesting talk and is useful in thinking about proposing new notations. YouTube: [VIDEO] If you search for t… — porcoda, 2023-02
Or ideas in general, should we ever gate keep the dissemination of ideas and knowledge? Innovation is more likely to occur when people cross disciplines and they can only do that if it is approachable, it is gradual and discoverable. Simple is hard, simplistic is easy. Someone is going to come back with essential vs accidental complexity [1] but we can always strive for simpler, more cohesive way… — seg_lol, 2020-10
(Nice to see your work shared here :) ) I went through the corresponding videos last year: [LINK] [LINK] It was a great refresher as someone who once liked math but hasn't done much of it in ~20 years :) I had seen the blog posts, but there was some "color" in the videos that helped. For example I didn't realize that the fonts sometimes matter! Honestly, I still don't really read the notation, as… — chubot, 2020-08
This is great! I wish I had seen something like this years ago. Related: "It's Time for a New Old Language" by Guy Steele. [VIDEO] He gives a history of metalanguage notations (for both language semantics and syntax, including regexes and CFGs). And then he criticizes the inconsistency that has cropped up in these notations over the years. The irony is that people who are formalizing precise sema… — chubot, 2018-01
Related videos
- Principles for Dealing with the Changing World Order by Ray Dalio · Principles by Ray Dalio · 43:42
- John Carmack Tech Talk with UMKC-SCE · UMKC School of Science and Engineering · 1:20:28
- "Data Driven UIs, Incrementally" by Yaron Minsky · Strange Loop Conference · 36:18
- Maybe Not - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:03:28
- The Clean Architecture in Python · Next Day Video · 49:53
- GopherCon 2016: The Design of the Go Assembler - Rob Pike · Gopher Academy · 23:56
- RustConf 2017 - Closing Keynote: Safe Systems Software and the Future of Computing by Joe Duffy · Confreaks · 42:45
- Dtrace Review · GoogleTalksArchive · 1:18:02
- "Testing Distributed Systems w/ Deterministic Simulation" by Will Wilson · Strange Loop Conference · 40:20
- Travis Oliphant: NumPy, SciPy, Anaconda, Python & Scientific Programming | Lex Fridman Podcast #224 · Lex Fridman · 3:05:24
- Armin Ronacher - A Python for Future Generations · EuroPython Conference · 42:43
- The Secret History of Silicon Valley · Google TechTalks · 56:32
- A Narrative History of BSD, Dr. Kirk McKusick · bsdconferences · 53:54
- How Python was Shaped by leaky Internals, Armin Ronacher, Flask framework · Видео с мероприятий {speach! · 49:55
- Jim Simons (full length interview) - Numberphile · Numberphile2 · 1:00:43
- Steve Jobs Stanford Commencement Speech 2005 · JoshuaG · 14:34