Robert F. Kennedy challenges Gross Domestic Product

Channel:ipyramid · Length:2:11 · Published:2008-09-11 · Views:378836

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short video of Robert F. Kennedy's 1968 speech criticizing Gross Domestic Product as a measure of progress, saying it counts everything except what makes life worthwhile.

Why HN recommends it

Quoted in economics threads about growth, work and basic income as a classic critique of GDP.

the best way to acknowledge that is to watch this speech from Robert F Kennedy — HN, 2020

Macroeconomics & financial crises · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

too much and for too long we seem to have surrendered personal excellence and Community value in the M accumulation of material things our gross national product now is over $800 billion a year but that gross national product if we judge the United States of America by that that gross national product counts air pollution and cigarette advertising and ambulances to clear our Highway of Carnage it counts special locks for our doors and the jails for the people who break them it counts the destruction of the Redwood and the loss of our natural wonders and chaotic frall it counts napon and it counts nuclear warheads and armored cars for the police to fight the riots in our cities it counts withman rifle and specs knife and the television programs which glorify violence in order to sell toys to our children if the gross national product does not allow for the health of our children the quality of their education or the joy of their play it does not include the beauty of our poetry or the strength of our marriages the intelligence of our public debate or the Integrity of our public official ials it measures neither our width nor our courage neither our wisdom nor our learning neither our compassion nor

On Hacker News

It depends. If it generate any kind of money exchange it counts to GDP. But there are many solutions that don't generate growth (like walking to work instead of using other means of transportation) The way we measure growth is nuts. the best way to acknowledge that is to watch this speech from Robert F Kennedy [VIDEO] — lcam84, 2020-02
I'd also be interested in effect on resource consumption. GDP isn't everything. I can't say it better than Kennedy: [VIDEO] — pqh, 2017-11
Although working fewer hours can mean more work (or at least a greater distribution of work), producing on a smaller scale is much more efficient than producing on a larger scale. This is due to Borsodi's law which states that as the cost of production decreases due to centralized operation, the cost of processing and distribution increases disproportionately [1]. For example, if a greenhouse pro… — lcam84, 2020-05
The problem with GDP per capita comparisons is that GDP is a bit of a weak measure of economic performance. It is a measure of raw, unadjusted economic throughput (cash flow, essentially), not necessarily a measure of economic performance. It is increased by an inefficient healthcare system (healthcare spending makes up 17.7% of the US GDP all on its own, while most of the affluent European count… — rbehrends, 2014-06

Related videos