Corruption is Legal in America

Channel:RepresentUs · Length:5:51 · Published:2015-04-30 · Views:2322938

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short RepresentUs explainer arguing that US politics is shaped by money, citing the Gilens and Page Princeton study on how little average citizens influence policy.

Why HN recommends it

Frequently linked as a compact summary of the Princeton study when commenters argue Congress ignores public opinion.

It's pretty compelling and well made. — HN, 2017

US politics & elections · Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

for the last few years I've had this sense that everything I learned as a kid about how America's government works is completely wrong but I had no idea how bad things actually were until I saw this one graph researchers at Princeton University looked at more than 20 years worth of data to answer a pretty simple question does the government represent the people now this is what they found this access here represents public support for any given idea on the left at 0% are ideas that not a single American want on the right at 100% are ideas that everyone supports this axis represents the likelihood of Congress passing a law that reflects any of these ideas from a zero to a 100% chance on this graph an ideal Republic would look like this if 50% of the public supports an idea there's a 50% chance of it becoming law if 80% of us support something there's an 80% chance you get the idea now most Americans would probably agree that with a few exceptions we should be as close to this ideal as possible unfortunately the way America actually works doesn't even come close take an idea that nobody supports literally nobody and it has about a 30% chance of becoming federal law now take an incredibly popular idea the most popular idea this

On Hacker News

I think this video will encourage you. Well actually maybe it will discourage you, but the follow up video will encourage you :D Corruption is Legal in America: [VIDEO] — auslegung, 2021-02
Today somebody on Reddit linked to this video which talks about the process of money influencing politics [VIDEO] It doesn't discuss the role of the judicial system. It's all about the legislative aspects of US government. It's pretty compelling and well made. Hopefully a bipartisan movement can have some impact. The video was made by [LINK] — rudimental, 2017-04
But would she have been if he didn't? You don't have to like him to acknowledge that the world's richest man with more followers than Joe Rogan has listeners (the most popular podcast period) has power. It's not inconceivable. When presidents do this they call it the "bully pulpit" because he uses his reach to the people to have them put pressure on their reps, which I wish we saw more of, becaus… — NaturalPhallacy, 2022-12
Power and office are two different things. Someone can exercise a great deal of power in advancing or killing legislation while never holding office and allowing all the office holders to call them names on TV. What matters is what policies are enacted. Here's a nice video on the topic that summarizes a Princeton study [VIDEO] — ihumanable, 2022-06
It's a tough issue, for sure, because the playing field is just so unequal. To even be able to approach these issues in a more equal way you'd probably have to start a lawsuit and go through a process of discovery because the corporation is bound by all these bizarre legal, financial, and political motives that don't apply when people are interacting with each other. This leads to corporations re… — cupcake-unicorn, 2021-12

Related videos