CNN treats politics like sports — and it’s making us all dumber

Channel:Vox · Length:6:02 · Published:2017-04-17 · Views:1690492

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Vox Strikethrough video arguing that CNN models its political coverage on sports shows like First Take, pitting pundits against each other. It claims this favors drama over truth and degrades public understanding.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as an example of how cable news turns politics into sports-style controversy, not recommended much as a watch.

US politics & elections · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

Trump has made CNN into an unlikely hero. You are fake news. Repeatedly criticizing the network for its coverage of his administration. Your ratings aren’t as good as some of the other people. That’s let CNN play the part of the embattled news network. Are we fake news, Kellyanne? Is CNN fake news? But the truth is a lot of this is theater. CNN plays a really important role in mainstreaming Trump’s misinformation. And that's because CNN’s approach to covering politics often prioritizes drama and spectacle over serious truth telling. If you want to understand how CNN covers Trump, you have to understand Jeff Zucker, the network’s president since 2013. Zucker came to the network from NBC, where he oversaw shows like Fear Factor and, yes, The Apprentice. His background is entertainment television, and to Zucker, politics is essentially a big game. He told New York Times magazine: Can’t believe that’s a real quote. Oh boy. You can see that approach in a lot of how CNN covers politics: flashy countdown clocks, dramatic graphics, pre- and post-debate panels. It’s essentially become the ESPN of politics. You a big ESPN fan? You know what… But the clearest parallel between CNN and typical sports coverage is the screaming matches.

On Hacker News

Much of our news media is currently designed to be sports-like, so if your goal is to be informed then this strategy is very wise. To make news more sports-like news channels like CNN offer generous pay to people that are willing to spout controversial cartoonish opinions on national news as explained here: [VIDEO] It is very questionable if these controversial opinions are representative of anyt… — asabjorn, 2017-11
> What is the point of this statement? I think he means that it's not spying or infiltration when the data is already there for everyone to see. It's about influence on one area that will affect the whole human species, not just one country, and people (esp politicians) are still very misinformed about the issue. It's about informing everyone, just the opposite of spying. > am I participating hon… — DiThi, 2017-04
Well, yes, if you watch "news". [LINK] [VIDEO] But there are real issues voted on. And even if there's no clear path forward, it's important to not go backward! > It's just "You are bad. No, YOU are bad" And? It's how ideas are criticized - ideally, by pointing out the errors in them. If someone uses ad hominem arguments, maybe try to find better people to listen to? (Economists, sociologists, po… — pas, 2017-06

Related videos