CNN, Feynman and the Challenger disaster

Channel:vsrr83 · Length:11:50 · Published:2015-05-19 · Views:692866

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A June 1986 CNN interview with physicist Richard Feynman about the Challenger disaster and the management failures he found while serving on the investigating commission.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it for Feynman's insights on NASA risk reasoning, blame and engineering culture, and the contrast between Apollo and the Shuttle.

Richard Feynman served on the Challenger commission and very nicely summarizes the difference between Apollo and Space Shuttle. — HN, 2025

Tech pioneers & interviews · Management, leadership & organizations · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

good evening here's what's happening the report on the space shuttle disaster is now in President Reagan's hands and the public will get a look at it on Monday tonight CNN's John Hollman reports some hard-fought battles among members of the investigative commission that wrote the report one member was harshly critical of NASA and therein lies the tale that John hullman unfolds now from Washington commission member Richard feineman charged that NASA had virtually ignored the principles of physics and good scientific practice in designing testing and building the space shuttle the Nobel prize winning physicist wrote a section of the final report known as chapter F commission sources say chairman William Rogers read the chapter and was Furious he called pinan to Washington Wednesday and urged him to tone down his criticism of NASA because chapter F threatened to destroy public confidence in the space agency binan returned to his home in California and began his rewrite but then changed his mind sources close to the scientists say he felt his ethics were being being compromised he sent a message to Rogers threatening to resign from the commission and demanding his name be taken off the final report if his chapter

On Hacker News

It was reusable, but way over promised. Don't take my word for it. Richard Feynman served on the Challenger commission and very nicely summarizes the difference between Apollo and Space Shuttle. [VIDEO] SpaceX is doing stuff that's just beyond the scope of what's deemed conventionally realistic. That's achievable and pushes us forward. — prasadjoglekar, 2025-08
> the model of 'public by default, opt in for security' is fundamentally daft in this context. It's daft in most contexts, and is one of the largest sources of security problems. If your design requires enumerating badness [1], you're doing it wrong. > from: [LINK] >> Just about every ICO, trust and company used the Parity multisig wallet, and that code was considered well-tested. -sigh- This is,… — pdkl95, 2017-07
> the absence of known danger is not the same as safety. Feynman had some interesting comments on this problem regarding NASA's "it worked ok last time" approach to risk assessment before the Challenger Disaster. [VIDEO] — pdkl95, 2016-02
Here is Richard Feynman talking about the issues [VIDEO] Seems not very different from how companies are managed 30 years later. — stepanhruda, 2016-01

Related videos