Christopher Hitchens - Free Speech

Channel:hitch archive · Length:21:08 · Published:2014-01-26 · Views:376801

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Christopher Hitchens delivers a speech defending freedom of speech, including the right of audiences to hear offensive speakers and a take on the fire-in-a-crowded-theatre line. It is framed around the Charlie Hebdo attack.

Why HN recommends it

HN invokes it in nearly every content moderation and censorship thread as the most eloquent case for free speech.

There is a brilliant speech by the late Christopher Hitchens [0] on free speech that I must have seen a dozen times. — HN, 2020

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] fire fire fire fire now you've heard it not shouted in a crowded theater admittedly as I realize I seem now to have shouted it in the Hogwarts dining [Music] room but the the point is made everyone knows the fatuous verdict of the greatly overpraised Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes who asked for an actual example of when it would be proper to limit speech or Define it as an action gave that of shouting fire in a crowded theater it's very often forgotten what he was doing in that case was sending to prison a group of yiddish-speaking socialists whose literature was printed in a language most Americans couldn't read opposing President Wilson's participation in the first world war and the dragging of the United States into this sanguinary conflict which the iish speaking socialists had fled from Russia to escape in fact it could be just as PL posibly argued that the yish speaking socialists who were jailed by the excellent and overpraised charge Oliver Wendell Holmes were the real firefighters were the ones who were shouting fire when there really was fire in a very crowded theater indeed and who is to decide well keep that question if you would ladies and gentlemen brothers and sisters I hope I may say comrades and friends before your

On Hacker News

My point is that you are then deigning someone to have the power to decide what is tolerant and what is not, when that is not nearly as acceptable or uncontroversial as you seem to be assuming. For example: > If progressives are pushing for more freedom, more tolerance, then to oppose it you have to, by definition, advocate for less of those. The framing of this is not correct. The problem is tha… — arminiusreturns, 2021-01
I've said it before and I'll say it again; it's the same justification that has been used to justify moves away from democracy. "Those poor dumb plebs, they just don't know any better, we, the elites, know whats best, so we should reduce the amount of democracy!" [1] 1. [LINK] You say "some moderation is required to prevent the apparent acceptance of some pretty hateful views along with conspirac… — arminiusreturns, 2020-10
There is a brilliant speech by the late Christopher Hitchens [0] on free speech that I must have seen a dozen times. An excerpt: “The freedom of speech is meaningless unless it means the freedom of the person who thinks differently... Don't take refuge in the false security of consensus, and the feeling that whatever you think you're bound to be okay because you're in the safely moral majority. .… — dlivingston, 2020-05
Christopher Hitchens yells fire in a crowded room here: [VIDEO] More importantly, his talk is worth watching for a strong understanding of why free speech is so vital. — Reedx, 2019-08
Back in 2007 Christopher Hitchens argued that Canada's hate speech laws are not only immoral but self-contradictory. The motion: "Be it resolved: Freedom of speech includes the freedom to hate." Hitchens was fully in favor of that statement.[1] His argument has three parts. First, freedom of speech isn't about the rights of the speaker. It's about the rights of people who want to listen to that p… — chroma, 2019-06

Related videos