Gender Neutral Pronouns: They're Here, Get Used To Them

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:3:48 · Published:2013-07-05 · Views:4569862

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott argues that grammatical gender is a silly concept and that the singular 'they' is an established gender-neutral pronoun. The description carries later corrections and reflections he added in 2019.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters link it as a short, friendly explanation of singular they and grammatical gender in discussions of pronoun usage.

Tom Scott has a great video on grammatical gender that is worth a watch — HN, 2013

Social issues & culture · Language & linguistics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Grammatical gender is the concept, found in about a quarter of the world's languages, that you can sort all nouns into male or female. La or le in French. Der, die, or das in German -- the das is for neuter. In Zande, which is found across a few countries in Central Africa, there are four grammatical genders: human male, human female, animate, and inanimate. There are occasional languages with even more complicated systems. Now, I'm a descriptivist linguist. I am not meant to judge whether language features are good or bad, I'm just meant to describe what they do. But grammatical gender is just such a stupid concept. I sort-of hate myself for saying that, but it's really silly. Oh, that's a computer, is it, French? So it's male. All computers are male. And that's a bottle, is it French? So it's female? All bottles are female? Really? Should I dress it up in a friggin' pink apron and give it a rolling pin as well? (Descriptivism, Tom. Don't judge.) I'm exaggerating, but I genuinely have tried searching the literature for any advantages of grammatical gender. There's only one vaguely convincing argument, which is that it can help clear up ambiguities and speeds up recognition of words by a small amount. Okay. But three-quarters

On Hacker News

> the word cromulent ... is not even a real word Only to a prescriptivist[1] trying to keep the language static. "Cromulent" is slowly making its way into descriptivist[1] dictionaries and is recognized about as often as any other new word, so it just as much a "real" word as other new words ("email", "google" (transitive verb), "truthiness"). > the correctness of using a singular they The altern… — pdkl95, 2015-08
Because no-one's posted it yet, Tom Scott has a great video on grammatical gender that is worth a watch: [VIDEO] — mdisraeli, 2013-12
They isn't just plural, it's also gender-neutral. Gender neutral pronouns: they're here to stay[1]. [1] [VIDEO] — tehwalrus, 2013-07

Related videos