Noam Chomsky - Freedom of Speech for Views You Don't Like

Channel:Chomsky's Philosophy · Length:10:15 · Published:2017-02-03 · Views:183148

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A ten-minute clip of Noam Chomsky on the Faurisson affair and free speech. He argues that supporting free speech means defending views you despise.

Why HN recommends it

HN quotes it in censorship and moderation threads for Chomsky's principle that free speech must cover speech you dislike.

If you're in favor of freedom of speech, that means you're in favor of speech precisely for views you despise — HN, 2021

Free speech, censorship & civil liberties · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

I don't mind the denunciations frankly I mind the lies I mean intellectuals are very good at lying they are professionals at it you a wonderful technique there's no way of responding to it if somebody calls you you know an anti-semite what can you say I'm not an anti-semite you know somebody says you're you're a racist you're a Nazi or something there's you always lose I mean the person who throws the mud always wins because there's no way of responding to such charges Professor chsky seems to believe that the people he criticizes fall into one of two classes Liars or dupes consider what happens when I discuss the case of Rober foris let me recall the facts uh let's not go into details please because the details happen to be important yes but I have only one question for S question do the facts matter or don't they matter of course they do let me tell you what the facts are first says that the that the massacre of the Jews in the Holocaust is a historic lie question no no this is an this is an important one has a lot to do with the topic your views are extremely controversial and perhaps one of the one of the things that has been most controversial and you've been most strongly criticized for was your defense of

On Hacker News

If you're asking this question, you don't understand the principles of freedom of speech. Read the Aaron Swartz essay linked above, and while you're at it, watch this, from Noam Chomsky: [VIDEO] . — sebmellen, 2020-10
"If you're in favor of freedom of speech, that means you're in favor of speech precisely for views you despise" - Noam Chomsky [VIDEO] — charbonneau, 2021-09
It's an irony that the kind of free speech you appear to support (and please correct me if I'm wrong) existed in fascist states like Nazi Germany and fascist Italy, because, as Chomsky points out here[1] "Goebbels was in favour of freedom of speech for views he liked". I'd suggest you might try the other path, as Chomsky also suggests: > “If you're in favour of freedom of speech that means you're… — brigandish, 2021-03
No. [VIDEO] Freedom of speech is not a small issue. It lies at the core of our civilization, and is unambiguously one of the few things that made "the West" prosper. Aaron makes a very cogent and clear argument for free speech, and its enduring importance. To arbitrate rights based on public opinion is idiotic and dangerous. This is why we have a constitution. Of course, Reddit has the right to d… — sebmellen, 2020-10
Dann haben wir haben ganz verschiedene Weltbilder. The right to religious criticism should be absolute. The reason I bring up the Austrian case is because itw was upheld by the ECHR, which Germany also defers to. To defend the woman in that case from the ECHR's deranged ruling: Scholars estimate that Mohammed married Aisha, his youngest wife, when she was only 6. If that is not paedophilia, I don… — sebmellen, 2020-10

Related videos