Yes Minister — Why Britain Joined the European Union

Channel:Hostis Humani Generis · Length:1:44 · Published:2016-03-18 · Views:1814907

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short Yes Minister clip in which the civil servant explains why Britain joined the European Union, delivered as satire of British foreign policy.

Why HN recommends it

HN posts it, often jokingly, as a prescient and witty explanation of Britain's ambivalent stance toward Europe, especially around Brexit.

The best explanation of this — HN, 2020

Geopolitics & foreign policy · Satire & parody

Subtitles (excerpt)

that the foreign office realize what damage this will do to the European idea well I'm sure they do that's why they support it well surely the foreign office is pro Europe isn't it yes and no if you'll forget the expression the foreign office is pro Europe because it is really anti- Europe the civil service was United in its desire to make sure that the common market didn't work that's why we went into it what are you talking about Minister Britain has had the same foreign policy objective for at least the last 500 years to create a disunited Europe in that cause we have fought with the Dutch against the Spanish with the Germans against the French with the French and Italians against the Germans and with the French against the Germans and Italians divide and Rule you see why should we change now when it's worked so well that's ancient history surely yes and current policy we had to break the whole thing up so we had to get inside we tried to break it up from the outside but that wouldn't work now that we're inside we can make a complete Pig's breakfast of the whole thing set the Germans against the French French against the Italians the Italians against the Dutch the foreign offic is terribly pleased

On Hacker News

The TV show "Yes, Minister" was a truly amazing show because of the brilliant writing, and how humorously it could speak the truth: Sir Humphrey Appleby: The Foreign Office is pro-Europe because it’s really anti-Europe. The civil service was united in its desire to make sure that the Common Market didn’t work. That’s why we went into it. Britain has had the same foreign policy objective for at le… — kstenerud, 2021-04
The UK was in favor of enlargement precisely because it would hinder integration. The best explanation of this: [VIDEO] — fmajid, 2020-12
> EU accounts have been signed off with a clean opinion every year since 2007. Whilst the debate about how accounts with errors could be signed off, the matter probably best covered here: [LINK] > That's equally applicable at the national level too Very true and politics as it stands needs an overall to align with modern times as akin to electing one tool to handle all issues for 4-5 years is nev… — Zenst, 2020-12
See [LINK] for lots of examples showing that regulatory capture is a real issue in Europe. The fact that you turn a blind eye towards it shows that jingoism isn't a purely American trait. And for the record, I grew up in Canada. I am not opposed to the idea of regulation in principle. However every approach has failure modes. And regulation works a lot better in practice when you exercise skeptic… — btilly, 2018-04
"I want my money back!" Margret Thatcher at the European Union summit in Dublin in 1980 "That such an unnecessary and irrational project as building a European superstate was ever embarked upon will seem in future years to be perhaps the greatest folly of the modern era. And that Britain, with her traditional strengths and global destiny, should ever have been part of it will appear a political e… — harryf, 2017-01

Related videos