The Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy

Channel:CRI · Length:1:02:37 · Published:2014-11-03 · Views:108658

Watch on YouTube

Summary

James D'Angelo argues that the 1970 Legislative Reorganization Act made congressional votes public, opening the door to lobbyists and special interests. He proposes restoring secret voting as a cheap fix for corruption and many social ills.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a long, evidence-backed theory for what changed in the 1970s and why Congress is broken, even when they are unsure they agree.

It is long, but well-reasoned and supported by a lot of evidence. Definitely worth a watch... — HN, 2016

US politics & elections · Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hello, this is James D’ Angelo. Today we are going to be jumping into a question that we discovered in democracy perhaps even a really big flaw with how American democracy is administered. And because the midterm elections are coming up and this is so important for ideas particularly with Congress, we are going to try to get this done by then. And the beauty of this is even though we see this fundamental flaw with democracy, one that is at the root of almost every problem in American society today, the reform is ridiculously cheap. In fact, we believe that all the problems that we run into can be solved with one single cardboard box. It sounds completely preposterous but hang in there because this is really easy to understand but it is really outrageous stuff. So when I was originally developing this video a few weeks ago, I called the video “Something Happened in the 70’s” because almost everywhere I was looking from economists to politicians to newspapers to journals, people were pointing their fingers at some mysterious event that happened sometime in the 70’s that precipitated an enormous amount of problems with our economy, our government and even our social institutions. And because this moment is so crucial, I’m going to run quickly through most of these

On Hacker News

This is very long but it goes into a well thought-out theory for why and how this happened. Very interesting stuff. Well worth a watch. [VIDEO] — kilroy123, 2022-05
This article kinda just glosses over any causes of lobbying, and then complains about the symptoms. There is one incredibly interesting video I have seen which lays out a major root cause of corruption in the US, and the rise of lobbying and corruption since the 1970s. [VIDEO] (Cardboard Box Reform) It is long, but well-reasoned and supported by a lot of evidence. Definitely worth a watch... — kbaker, 2016-04
We need to destroy their logic about "collecting everything, because they might need it in 100 years" first. They do it because it's so cheap, because they can, and because nobody is really standing up to them. However, if we allowed the government to do anything it wants "just because it can", thousands of our current laws wouldn't exist. I don't remember if it was Clapper or Alexander but one o… — higherpurpose, 2014-12
I ran across this theory years ago about a piece of legislation in late 1970 allowed lobbyists into previously closed door committee meetings, thus allowing lobbyists to assert direct pressure on congressional members. The second video is from the same guy but is rather long and goes into this idea that transparency in congressional committees is a counter-intuitively bad idea because it allows l… — jnellis, 2025-01
I think this group will appreciate this guy's analysis. "James D'Angelo (Winner 2014 MIT Climate CoLab, ex-NASA scientist) uncovers a crucial flaw in American democracy. Incredibly, the solution – which lays at the heart of all current social concerns (inequality, the recession, political division, government disapproval, Citizens United, civil rights and corruption) – costs under 5 dollars. Jame… — crispywisp, 2025-01

Related videos