John Carmack's keynote at Quakecon 2013 part 4

Channel:Kostiantyn Kostin · Length:29:59 · Published:2013-08-02 · Views:138884

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Part 4 of John Carmack's QuakeCon 2013 keynote, covering OpenGL, functional programming, Haskell, Lisp and Scheme, typing, multithreading, events and garbage collection.

Why HN recommends it

Cited again and again as Carmack's key public statement on functional programming and purity in game development, plus his remarks on garbage collection.

There's an old video [0] where he talks in-depth about his explorations of functional programming. — HN, 2024

Functional programming · Tech pioneers & interviews · Game programming & engines

Subtitles (excerpt)

that okay it's you know it's not evolving fast enough Microsoft's doing a spectacular job with what they're evolving with d3d but Along Came mobile and now webg and all of a sudden openg GL is what's you know is probably rendering 10 times as many triangles as uh you know as anything else and it's you know it's far from a perfect API uh all of the the implicit state in bindings is still you know a huge wart we still want lower level access to you know directly using buffers and uh some of the other things treating it like a CPU but it's still a good thing and I I can give myself a little bit of a a pat on the back for all the the work that I I did to kind of help make that happen over the years and I think that uh the industry as a whole is still is definitely better off for that and again it's it's not bad to have Microsoft doing a great job with all the d3d stuff uh but it's good to have a couple competing paradigms and something that was you know that wound up being free for the platforms that are going in thousands and thousands of different things so that's been a good thing I on the rendering side of things physically correct lighting it's wonderful to see that that's all the rage now it's all anybody's talking about for

On Hacker News

I think it is, and if you don't want to take my word for it, John Carmack thinks the same :) There's an old video [0] where he talks in-depth about his explorations of functional programming. It's perhaps a bit more about Haskell than about SICP, but in it he's also quite enthusiastic about what a veteran programmer can still learn from this book. [0] [VIDEO] — ookdatnog, 2024-06
Excellent read, I still remember a lot of it. There is also the accompanying Quakecon presentation where John Carmack talks at length about all this: [VIDEO] — lsh, 2019-01
What you describe above is similar to what Carmack discussed at his QuakeCon keynote several years back when toying with a game engine on Haskell. Very interesting talk, [VIDEO] — akmiller, 2017-09
The use of monads is a side-effect (ha!) of committing to purity throughout a language, and that's what FP is being equated to: pure statically-typed FP. (You can argue about how justified that is, of course. I'm not going into that, but you might want to see what John Carmack has to say[0]. No, he doesn't end by saying "we should all convert to the church of Haskell now", but he does talk about … — mrkgnao, 2017-08
Raymond Hettinger's talk about good code reviews -- [LINK] Carmack's talk about functional programming and Haskell -- [VIDEO] Jack Diederich's "Stop Writing Classes" -- [LINK] All with a good sense of humor. — sssilver, 2016-10

Related videos