Munk Debate on Artificial Intelligence | Bengio & Tegmark vs. Mitchell & LeCun

Channel:Policy-Relevant Science & Technology · Length:1:47:20 · Published:2023-06-24 · Views:118096

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Munk Debate on the proposition that AI research and development poses an existential threat. Yoshua Bengio and Max Tegmark argue for it, and Melanie Mitchell and Yann LeCun argue against.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a good debate with leading figures on both sides of the AI existential risk question.

Tis a good one — HN, 2023

AI safety, AGI & impact

Subtitles (excerpt)

you don't know which of your facts will be demolished you don't know which of your arguments will be totally destroyed and you now rattled you're shaken up and you don't know what the hell to say but you got to say something capitalism doesn't just have problems capitalism is broken I think it's time for this toxic binary zero-sum Madness to stop the biggest threat to the liberal International order [Music] paradoxically is not a non-liberal society like China but a liberal Society like the United States of America manipulated by flattery goaded by tweets his hand near the launch code when he overheats if he's that outrageous then you must think half of your countrymen are just completely Bonkers or more whatever you want to call this system a mafia state of feudal Empire it's a disaster for ordinary Russians having different opinions is so 20th century this Century we have different facts what a Pity we can't have a vote between who prefers bald Brits to curly head Canadians we don't require Divine permission to know right from wrong we don't need tablets administered to US 10 at a time in tablet form to be able to have a moral argument no do not want sympathy we do not want pity we want opportunities and that's why the whole thing whole thing

On Hacker News

All of the talk about "AI Safety" and "Effective Altruism" cannot be dismissed as BS. As technology has become more and more integrated into the very fabric of society, some dangers are very real unless we explicitly use Human standards of Morals/Ethics to regulate them. Of course this should be no excuse to go off into la-la land. From [LINK] Scholars discuss current risks from critical systems … — rramadass, 2023-11
Do you seriously think that the people that brought you pfas + other plethora of toxins and their subsequent effects across many systems really care about the dangers of AI? Please, enjoy it while it lasts. What they really need is big fat alien dick to come dick slap them across the face and bring them back to reality. Because of course there will be negative "known unknown" consequences and "un… — caliaihere, 2023-06
Very well said! The big problem is going to be some "not so intelligent" Human making decisions based on AI/ML output without verification or even worse having AI itself make the decision. Here is a Munk debate "AI research and development poses an existential threat" - Yoshua Bengio & Max Tegmark vs. Melanie Mitchell & Yann Lecun - [VIDEO] — rramadass, 2023-09
I just opened it up and found a fun bit during Melanie Mitchell's opener: [VIDEO] Paraphrasing: > Yoshua Bengio has written about a scenario where an AI is asked to solve climate change, and it designs a virus that decimates humans. Presto. No more humans, no more climate change. > This is an example of the fallacy of dumb superintelligence. It's a fallacy to think that a machine could be smarter… — civilized, 2023-06

Related videos