Using JSLint For Evil

Channel:ryantravistate · Length:2:44 · Published:2011-01-20 · Views:14786

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A three-minute clip in which Douglas Crockford explains why he allowed the JSLint reference implementation to be used for evil. It recounts the license clause and how corporate lawyers reacted.

Why HN recommends it

Linked in licensing threads as a short, funny story about the 'no evil' clause and IBM's request for an exception.

This reminds me of Douglas Crockford's classic story about the JSLint license — HN, 2020

Software practice, open source & careers · Software (other) · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

um so um let's see when I put the um reference implementation onto the website I need to put a software license on it and I looked at all the licenses that were available and there are a lot of them I decided the one I like the best was the MIT license which was a notice that you would put on your source and it would say you're allowed to use this for any purpose you want uh just leave the notice in the in the source and don't sue me um I I I love that license it's really good um but this was late in 2002 you know we just started the war on terror and you know we were going after the evildoers with the president and and the vice president and I felt like I need to do my part uh so so I added one more line to my license was that the software should be used for good not evil and that i' I've done my job um and about once a year I'll get a letter from a Frank who says I should have a right to use it for evil I'm not going to use it until you change your license or they'll write to me and say how do I know if it's evil or not I I don't think it's evil but someone else might think it's evil so I'm not going to use it great it's working my license works I'm stopping the evildoers for a separate

On Hacker News

David Crockford puts a "don't use this for evil" clause in the license for all software he releases, creating some interesting situations: [VIDEO] (2:44 and worth it) — SonOfLilit, 2017-07
See this 3 minute presentation fragment about the "Do not use JSLint for Evil" license clause: [VIDEO] — computer, 2013-10
That's what I was talking about. Crawford said in a talk he had to make an amended licenses for corporations (namely, IBM), who had lawyers that needed to be able to get around the evil restriction. [VIDEO] — easton, 2021-04
This reminds me of Douglas Crockford's classic story about the JSLint license containing a "The software shall be used for Good, not Evil" clause: [VIDEO] — tlrobinson, 2020-07
That doesn't work at all if it is the actual wording. For point 1 you can find warranty wording in any number of open source or creative commons licenses. For the second, objectionable requires a definition. For example many would consider the US drone assassination program objectionable, and hence tar US companies and people with the same brush. Does that mean US companies and people can use the… — rogerbinns, 2013-05

Related videos