Policing the internet in Germany, where hate speech, insults are a crime | 60 Minutes

Channel:60 Minutes · Length:13:13 · Published:2025-02-17 · Views:536807

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 60 Minutes segment on how German prosecutors and police go after online hate speech and insults, which are crimes there. It contrasts this with the broad First Amendment protection of online speech in the US.

Why HN recommends it

HN mostly cites it in unrelated threads as evidence of European speech restrictions, and some commenters call it propaganda.

Law, policing & justice · Free speech, censorship & civil liberties

Subtitles (excerpt)

if you've ever dared to read the comments on a social media post you might start to wonder if civilized discourse is just a myth aggressive threats lies and harassment have unfortunately become the norm online where anonymity has emboldened some users to push the limits of Civility in the United States most of what anyone says sends or streams online even if it's hate-filled or toxic is protected by the First Amendment as Free Speech but Germany is trying to bring some civility to the worldwide web by policing it in a way most Americans could never imagine in an effort it says to protect discourse German authorities have started Prosecuting online trolls and as we saw it often begins with a pre-dawn wakeup call from the police the story will continue in a moment it's 6:01 on a Tuesday morning and we were with State Police as they raided this apartment in Northwest Germany inside six armed officers searched a suspect's home then seized his laptop and cell phone prosecutors say those Electronics may have been used to commit a crime the crime posting a racist cartoon online at the exact same time across Germany more than 50 similar raids played out part of what prosecutors say is a coordinated effort to curb online hate speech in Germany what's the typical reaction

On Hacker News

> Trusted Flaggers > 1 Pimmel Affäre > Schwachkopf Affäre Oder zuletzt > [LINK] and last but not least: > [VIDEO] Germany is very much implementing censorship by chilling effect. — IlikeKitties, 2025-11
The UK arrested around 12.5k people in 2023 over social media posts, according to the Times. Not all of them related to immigration at all (but I would wager: many are). It is sufficient to 'cause distress' - against whom, or in what form, or what qualifies as 'distress' is deliberately kept vague to maximise persecution rates. Some cases saw a squad car with six Bobbies take the very average, mi… — DocTomoe, 2025-07
Germany, where they lock you up for criticizing politicians[1] or where they have a ban against protesting for Palestine because it's "antisemitic"?[2] Or UK where you can get locked up for blasphemy[3] or where they lock up ~30 people a day for saying offensive things online because of their Online Safety Act?[4] Or perhaps Romania where an election that didn't turn out the way the EU elites wan… — StanislavPetrov, 2025-06
I'm not the parent, but one reference they made but didn't link was this 60 Minutes clip "Policing the internet in Germany, where hate speech, insults are a crime". It was a bit of a meme in Germany. [VIDEO] Still, the author of the original article has some pretty polarising and crude views, and I think it's valuable to keep that context in mind. The key is not to be lazy and just dismiss everyt… — fwn, 2025-03
If you insist: [VIDEO] It was pretty heavily debated on r/DE. [LINK] Please tell me how you think this "protect one's honor" law doesn't get abused. Also, an youtuber from my country made a video during the pandemic exposing the mistreatment of seasonal fruit picking workers from my country working in Germany, and the video got blocked in Germany by Youtube, most likely on request by flagging. So… — FirmwareBurner, 2025-03

Related videos