Floyd Toole - Sound reproduction – art and science/opinions and facts

Channel:CIRMMT · Length:1:13:56 · Published:2015-05-14 · Views:144491

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Floyd Toole's CIRMMT distinguished lecture on the science of sound reproduction, drawing on decades of blind listening research. It covers what listeners prefer in loudspeakers and why measured accuracy and anechoic response matter.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a crash course on audio reproduction science, especially the finding that listeners reliably prefer more accurate speakers in blind tests.

In blind testing, the average listener reliably prefers the more accurate speaker. — HN, 2023

Audio & video engineering · University lectures & courses

Subtitles (excerpt)

Good afternoon everyone and uh what can I say after that? Uh I'm going to try to hush along be a little hasty here because uh times have passing and we have as I say some sound production coming after us here. Art and opinions are shown here in multiple colors and shades because that's really what they are. It's whatever you want it to be. Whatever art is whatever you want it to be. Opinions are whatever they happen to be. But I come from the science side of things. It's black and white. It's reality. It's there or it's not there. It's repeat. If it's good, if it's accurate, it's repeatable. You can do it today, tomorrow, here, or in Timbuktu and get the same answers. Science is different from art. Science is different from opinions. And yet they go together. They must go together. In fact, if they don't, we we will fail at our our enterprise of entertaining the world with with wonderful art, sound production, the real thing happening on stage like this. It's it's it is art in real time. And it'll do two performances may never be exactly the same. That's just what re That's what it is. Sound reproduction. You put two letters in front of it. re and the world changes because you're going to try to capture a performance

On Hacker News

This is actually a common misconception. In blind testing, the average listener reliably prefers the more accurate speaker. There is a talk [1] by Dr. Floyd Toole that is an excellent crash course on the science of sound reproduction and listener preference. [1] [VIDEO] — Humbly8967, 2023-11
No mention of Toole? Obligatory considering the subject, even if it's about acoustics and not digital audio: [LINK] And a talk by the author covering some of the material for those who prefer that: [VIDEO] — BoingBoomTschak, 2026-07
EQing for a flat in room response is NOT ideal! Correcting a speaker requires measuring the *anechoic* response, and only the bass should be tuned to subtract the room's effect. This video [1] provides a crash course on science of audio reproduction. [1] [VIDEO] — Humbly8967, 2025-10
FYI, when attempting to apply this to speakers, the anechoic frequency response is required. If you try to equalize for flat-in-room response, the results are terrible. See this video[1] for loads more information and context. [1] [VIDEO] — Humbly8967, 2025-04
It's an article written by Floyd E. Toole, Ph.D., who was Vice President - Acoustical Engineering at Harman International from 1991 until he retired in 2007. "His research focused primarily on the acoustics and psychoacoustics of sound reproduction. Most notably, he established methods for subjective and objective evaluations which have been used to clarify the relationships between technical mea… — lioeters, 2021-03

Related videos