Longer-lasting light bulbs: it was complicated

Channel:Technology Connections · Length:33:33 · Published:2023-07-16 · Views:2351969

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Technology Connections examines why light bulbs have the lifespans they do, including the real history of the Phoebus cartel. He shows that bulb life trades off against brightness and efficiency rather than being simple planned obsolescence.

Why HN recommends it

HN's go-to link for correcting the lightbulb conspiracy myth, giving an engineer's view of the lifespan versus efficiency tradeoff.

highly recommended if you want an engineers perspective, with no 'great conspiracy' hype. — HN, 2024

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Engineering & making (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

Planned obsolescence - it’s an insidious thing. A business that designs the perfect product which lasts forever will run out of customers once everybody has one. And running out of customers is a pretty bad strategy for a business which strives to be immortal. This simple reality, when viewed with a slightly twisted mindset, can be seen as a reason to never build the perfect product, and it is often argued - quite convincingly, I should say - that companies today are actively making their products worse to guarantee you’ll have to buy another one before too long. Now, I’m not here to make any accusations. Though I do certainly wish to see us endowed with a right to repair the things we own, and maybe some other things while we’re at it. Uh, anyway, though I won’t comment on what may or may not be happening today, between the first and second world wars, an actual, documented conspiracy between light bulb manufacturers across the globe existed. The Phoebus cartel, an arrangement between Osram, Philips, General Electric, and several others, established a maximum light bulb life expectancy of 1,000 hours. The organization even conducted tests on each other’s products and issued fines to its members when their light bulbs took just a little too long to burn out.

On Hacker News

There is an excellent video about Lightbulb Cartel by Technology Connections, highly recommended if you want an engineers perspective, with no 'great conspiracy' hype. [VIDEO] — samat, 2024-07
For an even deeper dive into this topic... Technology Connections: Longer-lasting light bulbs: it was complicated [VIDEO] — mreome, 2026-07
It's true that the Phoebus cartel arranged to have light bulbs die after a certain number of hours, but bulb lifetime is a trade off between lumens, filament life, and energy consumption. The cartel-defined lifetime limit sits very close to the sweet spot for all of those metrics for incandescent bulbs. Technology Connections explained this well in a video about a year ago: [VIDEO] — RulerOf, 2024-11
Actually Technology Connections made a great youtube video on this: [VIDEO] The gist is that by running bulbs at a lower power, you can greatly prolong its life, but the downside is that it doesn't heat up as much, and since emissions spectrum correllates with temperature, ends up being much worse at converting electricity to light, which ends up being not worth it. — torginus, 2024-08
Nice video from the well known channel Technology Connections: [VIDEO] => It's complicated. Yes, there was a cartel, but it was not all bad. There were legitimate reasons to go for 1000h light bulbs. — mmkhd, 2024-06

Related videos