James Tour: The Mystery of the Origin of Life

Channel:Discovery Science · Length:58:01 · Published:2019-03-18 · Views:952539

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Synthetic organic chemist James Tour gives a lecture arguing that origin-of-life research is far from explaining how life began. The talk was published by the Discovery Institute and drew sharp criticism.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended by some as a blunt expert critique of origin-of-life research, while others question its claims and length.

Here's a talk by one of the world’s top synthetic organic chemists offering a blunt assessment of the current state of origin of life research — HN, 2019

Chemistry · Evolution & genetics · Religion, belief & skepticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] so I'm gonna haven't gonna stand off to the side here because I've got to look back at them and like in the old days where you have to look back at the slides and use a laser pointer rather than so go ahead to the next slide this is just an overview of some of the work that we do in our group because because many times there will be criticisms of those who speak at conferences like this that they're not not practicing scientists that they they read papers and they write books but I write very few books in fact I've only written one book and I'll never do that again and I've written chapters for books it but only at great urging usually I just published papers we published papers and journals that's what we do in my world and so we work in a number of different areas and the reason I'm telling you all this is because I want you to see that I really am a practicing scientist and this is I rarely attend conferences like this I'm usually in conferences with with scientists and engineers but we work in an area called laser induced graphene that's where we can take this is a polyamide sheet and hit it with a laser and write patterns of graphene graphene is single sheets of graphite one atom thick and it's the strongest material known at that level and

On Hacker News

> Afaik we are very close to artificially creating living cells. This is one recent example [1]. I beg to differ. It may look impressive on the surface, just like GPT-3 looks impressive on the surface, but is far from the real thing. It is just another extension of the ladder to the Moon. The effort described in the article is nowhere near a living cell. It lacks protein building and DNA/RNA mech… — freediver, 2022-04
Oh, well the 'current' argument is that it's unlikely for a bunch of reasons. - cambrian explosion of life is seen as unlikely given that changing random genes or dna mutations has such a low success rate in generating new life, that an explosion of life happening all at once seems out of step with the math. - we don't know how to create life at all. adding up bits and pieces of molecules into ce… — friendlybus, 2020-11
Here's a talk by one of the world’s top synthetic organic chemists offering a blunt assessment of the current state of origin of life research: [VIDEO] — taejavu, 2019-08
From the first comment: > "amino acids don't hook together by themselves" [VIDEO] This is a very weird remark considering that the article posted here is about how amino acids hook together by themselves, and which amino acids hook in the correct way and which hook in the incorrect way. --- It's a long talk (1h). Which are the main points? I only skimmed, so I hope I have a not very unfair select… — gus_massa, 2019-08

Related videos