Are Planes With Parachutes Really Safer?

Channel:AVweb · Length:13:43 · Published:2019-03-18 · Views:1002945

Watch on YouTube

Summary

AVweb's Paul Bertorelli analyzes the safety record of the Cirrus Airframe Parachute System (CAPS), looking at the 90-plus deployments over 20 years of Cirrus flying. He asks whether the whole-aircraft parachute has actually saved lives.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in aviation-accident threads as a compact analysis of whether whole-aircraft parachutes work, with the track record described as impressive.

AVweb did an interesting video a couple of years ago — HN, 2022

Aviation & aerospace engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] you can hit pause if you've heard this one two guys walk into a bar there are plain guys one says to the other hey how about this we put a rocket in the baggage compartment of an airplane and then we tie a parachute to it and if the pilots about to crash or he gets scared he can push a button and lower the whole thing to the ground who would do this who would believe it well these two guys did that's Alan and Dale clap Meyer this guy sold into parachute his name is Boris Popov his company is called ballistic recovery systems and while you weren't looking or maybe thinking about it this parachute system called the Cirrus aircraft parachute system or caps has been out there flying for 20 years yep that long but it's still enough of a novelty that if there's a camera around and when is there not a camera around the footage will make the evening news not quite up to Russian dashcam standards maybe but I caching nonetheless now I wouldn't say all pilots are egotistical jerks exactly but we can be kind of funny you know like somehow you're not a real pilot if you got to fly around with a parachute to pull your fat out of the fire so when the Cirrus parachute system first appeared the whisper campaign started right away like the first pole would be on the

On Hacker News

AVweb did an interesting video a couple of years ago, "Are Planes With Parachutes Really Safer?": > The Cirrus line of aircraft have been flying for 20 years and although most people in aviation know they have full aircraft parachutes, it's fair to ask how effective these have been. With more than 90 uses of the so-called CAPS, has the system really saved lives? In this video, AVweb's Paul Bertor… — throw0101c, 2022-09
Here's an analysis of the CAPS system's safety record: [VIDEO] (contains some good footage of an SR22 parachuting into the ocean, and into the ground). This is a good overview on the survivability of water landings: [LINK] . I haven't watched the video recently but I think even a 172 that cartwheels after landing has a pretty good survivability rate, something like 90%. Parachute is a nice to hav… — jrockway, 2021-05
There's precedent. [LINK] [30s] [VIDEO] [15m] The Cirrus system is deployed by rockets, allowing it to function at a very low altitude. They say that you should deploy it no matter what altitude you are at, and it will add at least some friction. The system has a very impressive track record. However, at this altitude, with an airplane this heavy, you might have to put the rockets on the plane to… — maxbond, 2025-07
Perhaps some private planes (Cirrus) are better equipped to survive losing a wing, since they have rocket-deployed parachutes. Somewhat boring video of the parachute in action ("boring" being a synonym for "an amazing triumph of safety engineering"): [LINK] 14m video essay about the system: [VIDEO] (Reporting says this was an Embraer, this is strictly a tangent.) — maxbond, 2023-08

Related videos