SICP / What is "Computer Science" ?

Channel:LarryNorman · Length:10:00 · Published:2006-09-12 · Views:131168

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An excerpt from Hal Abelson's opening SICP lecture introducing computer science and contrasting declarative and imperative knowledge. He argues that computer science is not really a science and is more like magic or engineering of ideas.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in debates over whether computer science is a science, and for Abelson's line that it is neither a science nor about computers.

Computer Science is a terrible name for this business. First of all, its not a science. — HN, 2014

Functional programming · Computability & complexity theory · University lectures & courses

Subtitles (excerpt)

Actually, that's a terrible way to start. Uh, computer science is a terrible name for this business. First of all, it's not a science. It uh might be engineering or it might be art. Or we'll actually see that computer so-called science actually has a lot in common with magic. We'll see that in this course. So, it's not a science. It's also not really very much about computers. And it's not about computers in the same sense that that physics is not really about particle accelerators and uh biology is not really about microscopes and petri dishes and uh it's not about computers in the same set sense that geometry is not really about uh using surveying instruments. In fact, there's a lot of uh commonality between computer science and geometry. Geometry first of all is another subject with a lousy name. The name comes from Gaia meaning the earth and metron meaning to measure. Geometry originally meant measuring the earth or or surveying. And the reason for that was that thousands of years ago, the Egyptian priesthood developed the rudiments of geometry in order to figure out how to restore the the boundaries of fields that were destroyed in the annual flooding of the Nile. And to the Egyptians who did that, geometry really was the use of surveying

On Hacker News

"Anything which uses science as part of its name isn't: political science, creation science, computer science." - Hal Abelson I would also recommend the first minutes of [VIDEO] — tyn, 2008-09
Hal Abelson disagrees with you. "Computer Science is a terrible name for this business. First of all, its not a science. It might engineering, or it might be art. But we'll actually see that computer -- so-called science -- actually has a lot in common with magic."[1] 1. [VIDEO] — kylebrown, 2014-08
Feynman's view on CS is similar by Hal Abelson's take on the term (see [VIDEO] ). Abelson's point about CS being more like magic has always stuck with me. — imaginaryunit, 2012-02
It is not a science. It is also not about computers. :) SICP lecture 1 -- [VIDEO] But maybe it is a science: there are certainly a number of things in CS that yield facts about things like algorithms (Big O, etc). I read other comments here that compare computer science to math, and it is not an unfair comparison. However, even amongst mathematicians, you will see something of an avoidance to ass… — Xurinos, 2010-10

Related videos