Does Superdeterminism save Quantum Mechanics? Or does it kill free will and destroy science?

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:20:30 · Published:2021-12-18 · Views:992925

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains superdeterminism as an interpretation of quantum mechanics, addressing common objections and misconceptions, including the worry that it kills free will or science. She ties it to Bell's theorem and hidden variables.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a clear explanation of Bell's theorem and superdeterminism, though some criticize it as knocking down strawmen.

The video does the subject justice much better than I can — HN, 2021

Quantum physics · Consciousness & cognition

Subtitles (excerpt)

Superdeterminism is a way to make sense of quantum mechanics. But some physicists and philosophers have argued that if one were to allow it, it would destroy science. Seriously. How does superdeterminism work, what is it good for, and why does it allegedly destroy science? That’s what we’ll talk about today. First things first, what is superdeterminism? Above all, it’s a terrible nomenclature because it suggests something more deterministic than deterministic and how is that supposed to work? Well, that’s just not how it works. Superdeterminism is exactly as deterministic as plain old vanilla determinism. Think Newton’s laws. If you know the initial position and velocity of an arrow, you can calculate where it will land, at least in principle. That’s determinism: Everything that happens follows from what happened earlier. But in quantum mechanics we can only predict probabilities for measurement outcomes, rather than the measurement outcomes themselves. The outcomes are not determined, so quantum mechanics is indeterministic. Superdeterminism returns us to determinism. According to superdeterminism, the reason we can’t predict the outcome of a quantum measurement is that we are missing information. This missing

On Hacker News

Randomly found a link to this video on super determinism from his blog and found it super interesting. 100% agree, what is 'free will' anyways? A concept with no scientific definition. Why is it even used to explain anything in quantum mechanics? [VIDEO] — trixie_, 2022-01
Wow. I actually just saw [a video from Sabine Hossenfelder]( [VIDEO] ) about exactly this. Long story short, we don't know if quantum nonlocality is real. Bell's Theoreom doesn't prove nonlocality. It proves that locality is impossible with statistical independence, that is, the measurement itself affects the quantum system. We can preserve locality if we also accept superdeterminism, which Sabin… — quocanh, 2021-12
Some say that it has not been fully proved there are no hidden variables. [VIDEO] (Sabine Hossenfelder on Superdeterminism) — rjprins, 2024-09
It cannot, even if ppl think that this is what Bell's theorem says. But the determinism must be quite strange: [VIDEO] — raindeer2, 2024-05
I question your assumption that in history “things don't happen in history because of (truly) random behaviors converging on some emergent effect.” Firstly there is currently a debate among quantum physics as to the true randomness of what we observe[1][2]. Turns out we don’t actually need true randomness in our models, they just need to appear as if they are random, in other words, the chaotic n… — runarberg, 2023-04

Related videos