The Epidemic of Fake Disease

Channel:Medlife Crisis · Length:20:57 · Published:2020-02-25 · Views:2431697

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Medlife Crisis video by cardiologist Rohin Francis on overdiagnosis and over-screening. It explains how detecting more disease does not necessarily mean saving more lives, and covers harms such as unnecessary treatment.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in threads about cancer screening, PSA tests, full-body MRIs and consumer diagnostics as an explanation of why more testing can hurt.

This video does a good job also of covering the topic of over-testing/over-treating potential cancer — HN, 2021

Medicine & infectious disease · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I've got my myocardial themed tea ready because today we're going to talk about fake disease we're living in the era of fake news after all so it's only fitting and I'm not talking about selfie itis or affluenza I mean things like cancer so what am I going on about well this episode is about when cancer isn't cancer [Music] have you ever thought about getting one of those full-body scams you know the kind a very emotive advert perhaps on the train with a grieving wife and children if only that dead fool had come in for our cancer screening service he'd still be with his family today they work on scare mongering and pretty much make it sound like it's almost your fault if you get some horrible disease because you simply weren't paying close enough attention to your health and that's why you should spend 99999 now I'm not gonna tell you what to do with your money but I'm certainly not going to spend any of my own on a well man checkup or full body scan and I'll try to explain why the concepts in this video are some of the hardest to grasp in the whole of medicine so I'm not going to try and cover too much in this video and I'm sure we can revisit things in future videos some of the things you'll

On Hacker News

It does, doesn't it! This is basically the reason scepticism in screening has risen (amongst scientists and medics, not the general population) - research seems to show that screening catches much more cancer but doesn't save many more people. Rohin Francis does a good video on it, which you don't have to watch because it has references underneath you can click straight through to (the video is g… — jamesbelchamber, 2026-02
I'd encourage you to think about the consequences of over testing. Although it is somewhat counter intuitive, there are many negative consequences to patient outcomes from overtesting. A deeper overview: [VIDEO] — fooblaster, 2022-09
Compare and contrast this video from 'Medlife Crisis': [VIDEO] > Trying to detect disease early seems like an obviously good thing to do. But reality isn't always quite so straightforward, especially in medicine. If It Ducks Like A Quack is a series where I try to go beyond the hype and explore how complicated the apparently simple phenomena in medicine are. One point from the video: five year su… — eru, 2021-12
This video does a good job also of covering the topic of over-testing/over-treating potential cancer (or creating "Fake Disease" as it terms it): [VIDEO] — Someone1234, 2021-11
This one is even more relevant as he talks about dangers of over screening for beast cancer, and side effects of mastectomy+chemo: [VIDEO] — ejolto, 2021-05

Related videos