Feynman: How the train stays on the track FUN TO IMAGINE 7

Channel:Christopher Sykes · Length:2:27 · Published:2008-09-05 · Views:820248

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip from the 1983 BBC series Fun to Imagine in which Richard Feynman explains how a train stays on the track. He covers the geometry of tapered wheels that steer the train back toward the center of the rails.

Why HN recommends it

HN people link it as Feynman's charming and clear explanation of why train wheels are tapered, whenever trains, bicycles or steering come up.

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

A harder one and very entertaining was what keeps a train on the track. And of course the answer is as everyone thinks the flanges on the wheels. You know the wheels have some kind of flange on them. But that's not the answer because those flanges are just safety devices. If the flanges rub against the tracks you hear a terrible squealing. They're just in case the real mechanism doesn't work. There's another problem with trains that's connected to it that people all know this about their automobile that when you go around a corner, the outside wheels have to go further than the inside wheels. And if the front if the wheels were connected on a solid shaft, you couldn't do that. You can't turn the outside wheels further than the inside wheels. And so the shaft is broken in the middle with a gear system. It's called a differential. Did you ever see the differential on a railroad train? No. No, you look at those wheels under a freight car and there are the two wheels and there's a solid steel rod going from one wheel to the other. There's nothing that one turns the same as the other. So now, how does it go around a corner? A curve when the outside wheel has to go further than the inside wheel.

On Hacker News

That doesn’t seem to be a charitable reading and in any case it has to do with wheel taper, more like cone than cylinder. More specifically the nature of the solution was getting two parts of the org, track and train, to work together. While that may seem elementary stuff, anyone at a big org can attest to how often it is tremendously difficult to do sometimes. I write this not as an apologist fo… — adolph, 2022-09
Indeed. Feynman talked in ‘surely you’re joking..’ about his affection for MIT students in his fraternity setting one another puzzles, and he talked about the question of how trains go round corners being one he found particularly interesting. In fact he repeats it in this interview: [VIDEO] He doesn’t answer the question ‘how does a train stay on the track’ with ‘some trains don’t’; he doesn’t s… — jameshart, 2021-07
> doesn't a speed change imply a force on the bearing .... imply friction Not necessarily. A speed change could also be because the track is longer. That's how trains stay on the tracks, the wheels are slanted, and if they turn off the track the length of the wheel changes, which changes the speed (relative to the wheel on the other side) and steers it back onto the track. Feynman explains it: [V… — ars, 2015-05
If Feynman were still around, he'd set things straight. I don't think a bicycle staying upright is much different from a train keeping course [1], but I can't describe why. Instead of the rail veering off and the wheel adapting, it's like the bike does what it wants and the ground shifts beneath it. If you've read about Einstein's pail-of-milk-on-a-lazy-susan, it's a similarly unintuitive frame o… — arh68, 2013-08

Related videos