Single Point of Failure: The (Fictional) Day Google Forgot To Check Passwords

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:13:05 · Published:2014-01-16 · Views:2363255

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott performs a fictional story at GeekyConf about the day Google accidentally stops checking passwords, letting anyone into any account. It works as a parable about how a single point of failure in login can unravel everything built on it.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it as the canonical thought experiment whenever authentication failures, account compromises or Google outages come up.

It's basically the scenario Tom Scott laid out about what would happen if Google stopped checking passwords — HN, 2021

Security & hacking · Documentaries & storytelling

Subtitles (excerpt)

In the aftermath, when everything had been started to recover and people had more or less tidied up and the stock markets had started to recover from the trillions of dollars wiped off them, Google's network engineers said that were only five people in the world who are able to approve changes to their most critical code. And each one of those five was entirely trusted. July 4th. In Western Europe, it is Friday afternoon, and office workers are looking at their clocks and trying to work out if it's okay to leave work early. In America, they are gearing up for a three-day Independence Day weekend. Over at Google's headquarters in Mountain View, most of the building is deserted; on-call engineers are either at home, their phones ready to buzz if anything goes wrong, or they're pulling late-night shifts in datacentres located around the world. There is one well-lit office, though, hidden away in a quiet corner of the building. In it is Maria Christensen, one of Google's most senior engineers and one of the Trusted Five. She is, against all corporate procedure, rolling out a change to Google's core infrastructure code. She's changed only one section: and it's the very first part of the login code for Google

On Hacker News

Single Point of Failure: The (Fictional) Day Google Forgot To Check Passwords - [VIDEO] is another, different topic, but still worth watching. — richardwhiuk, 2023-05
When YouTube comes back up again, I can recommend Tom Scott with "Single Point of Failure: The (Fictional) Day Google Forgot To Check Passwords" [VIDEO] — zaxomi, 2018-10
So I have a service using openid and I use google to authenticate the person logging in. I do that, then that's done. Now I could simply issue a session cookie, or a permament cookie, to the client so we never have to use google again. Or I could make it so that cookie lasts 10 minutes before reauthentication. I can use a refresh token which means they don't need to reauthenticate but if google e… — iso1631, 2022-04
Google's entire business hinges on user privacy from everyone other than Google. If, tomorrow, either this Account Security scenario happened[0] or this South Park website happened[1] (everyone's internet history searchably by anyone), and it was done at the incompetence of Google, they would crumble overnight. They might recover within a year or two if they release a statement and fix it within … — judge2020, 2022-03
Just reading the title it sounded very much like "Single Point of Failure: The (Fictional) Day Google Forgot To Check Passwords": [VIDEO] — SahAssar, 2021-07

Related videos