Jonathan Blow on scripting languages
Channel:Jeru Sanders · Length:9:30 · Published:2019-06-02 · Views:186957
Summary
A 10-minute clip from a Jonathan Blow Twitch stream in which he argues that game engines do not really need separate scripting languages. He questions the value of embedded interpreters when the main language can do the job.
Why HN recommends it
Cited in threads about Lua, embedded scripting, and game engines as a concise argument that scripting languages are redundant.
Jonathan Blow has a great talk on the redundancy of scripting languages in game engines. — HN, 2022
Programming language design · Game programming & engines
Subtitles (excerpt)
The very concept of a scripting engine today in the year or a scripting language today in the year 2020 is a bad sign. Like that's something that games gave up on in like 2005 for those of us who know what's going on. So like the fact that it still uses a scripting language to do things in 2020 is a bad sign, but the rest of the engine might be good. Uh yeah, scripting languages are not good. So here's the thing. This is what mainstream serious game developers discovered many years ago. We had this idea first like, "Oh, let's put in scripting languages because look, it'll improve your iteration time because you don't have to recompile the engine to make gameplay code changes. Um it'll enable non-serious programmers like your art team and stuff to to do stuff on the levels. And that'll be really good." Um So what what actually happens in reality is several things. First of all your engine has to interface with the scripting language for everything you want people to be able to do. It has to provide all these hooks. Those are annoying and obnoxious. And uh they're very bug prone. And it causes a lot of programming time just to be able to add those hooks first of all. Uh secondly the scripting language itself inevitably ends up being
On Hacker News
There’s nothing about this that screams “this language needs to be created”. Call me a pessimist, but I’ve seen So many toy languages on HN. My advice is, if you don’t have any original ideas and want users, your best bet is to implement a subset of JS, that’s the route I’m taking. Jonathan Blow has a great talk on the redundancy of scripting languages in game engines. [VIDEO] — pipeline_peak, 2022-12
Lua doesn’t really solve anything fundamental. It’s popular because it’s small and easy to embed. But embeddable interpreters, while fun pet projects, they’re redundant and trivial. Jonathan Blow has a great explanation of this [VIDEO] Write reusable libraries first, let people embed them into whatever scripting language/GUI app they want. Scripting languages, Linux distros, it’s all Pokémon card… — pipeline_peak, 2022-10
"Gaming engines are scriptable for a reason" - I'm sure I've heard the opposite opinion from respectable sources at least 2 times. Here's Jonathan Blow [VIDEO] I agree with the rest wholeheartedly. — veidelis, 2021-05
> I can guarantee you that a game will need a scripting language. Better get that done already. Is that really so certain? [VIDEO] — pengaru, 2020-08
Related videos
- How Python was Shaped by leaky Internals, Armin Ronacher, Flask framework · Видео с мероприятий {speach! · 49:55
- Why Isn't Functional Programming the Norm? – Richard Feldman · Metosin · 46:09
- Overwatch Gameplay Architecture and Netcode · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:04:03
- Maybe Not - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:03:28
- Conway's Game Of Life in APL · Dyalog · 7:47
- Lecture 1A | MIT 6.001 Structure and Interpretation, 1986 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 1:12:55
- Crockford on JavaScript - Volume 1: The Early Years · YUI Library · 1:42:08
- Growing a Language, by Guy Steele · Bill Pugh · 53:31
- Effective Programs - 10 Years of Clojure - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:14:51
- Brian Goetz - Stewardship: the Sobering Parts · ClojureTV · 1:03:30
- RustConf 2018 - Closing Keynote - Using Rust For Game Development by Catherine West · Rust Programming Language · 42:29
- A Deep Dive into Nanite Virtualized Geometry · SIGGRAPH Advances in Real-Time Rendering · 1:09:59
- JavaScript: The Good Parts · Google TechTalks · 1:03:47
- How Crash Bandicoot Hacked The Original Playstation | War Stories | Ars Technica · Ars Technica · 31:37
- Jonathan Blow - How to program independent games - CSUA Speech · Alexandre Franco · 1:15:50
- Ideas about a new programming language for games. · Jonathan Blow · 1:55:24