Milton Friedman - The Negative Income Tax

Channel:LibertyPen · Length:14:45 · Published:2012-05-11 · Views:569226

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A 1968 Firing Line interview in which Milton Friedman explains the negative income tax, a proposal to replace welfare bureaucracy with direct payments.

Why HN recommends it

The go-to primary source in basic income threads for Friedman's negative income tax idea.

here's a nice intro — HN, 2019

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Labor, work & inequality

Subtitles (excerpt)

if it's true that positive action by government is a mistake in as much as it tends to exacerbate situations that it set out to cure uh wouldn't it follow that your proposal for a negative income tax might actually create a larger class of indolent and uh and unemployed than existing programs or certainly than ideal programs but first of all you better you'd better uh explain your negative income tax because it's it's frequently misunderstood yes it certainly is the uh the proposal for a negative income tax is a proposal to help poor people by giving them money which is what they need rather than as Now by requiring them to come before a governmental official detail all their assets and their liabilities and be told that you may spend X Dollar on rent y Dollar on food Etc and then be given a handout the idea of the negative income tax is to treat people who are poor in the same way as we treat people who are rich both groups would have to file income tax returns and both groups would be treated in parallel way under current law if you or I file an income tax return and we have let's say I were a family of four head of a family of four to take a simple kid in fact you do well I am but as it happens my

On Hacker News

When people focus on inequality, are they doing so because they love the poor and want to do something for them, or because they hate/envy the rich? Too often, it's the latter. Instead of UBI, a negative income tax is a much better approach. There's a lot of info out there about it, but here's a nice intro: [VIDEO] — tomohawk, 2019-03
What I really don't get is, why do everyone advocate for universal basic income, instead of a negative income tax. The negative income tax model achieves the same basic income with less negative motivation for people who want to pursue work at the low-end. It also avoids wastefully paying it to people who don't need it. This is my inspiration : [VIDEO] — andriesm, 2017-03
Friedman himself would disagree with you. He supported a related idea - a negative income tax. Hear him describe it here: [VIDEO] . This is not a capitalism vs socialism or left vs right issue. — raleighm, 2016-12
Which is the point of the deduction. Any work at all is better than sitting around doing nothing. - I'd suggest you check out Friedman's original position. [VIDEO] It's elegant. — jfoutz, 2014-08
There's still an incentive to work with a negative income tax. This is an interesting discussion about it: [VIDEO] — backprojection, 2013-10

Related videos