Was Penrose Right? NEW EVIDENCE For Quantum Effects In The Brain
Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:19:19 · Published:2024-07-25 · Views:1119091
Summary
PBS Space Time examines Roger Penrose's idea that consciousness arises from quantum processes in the brain, and reviews new evidence about microtubules. It ends with an estimate of what replicating consciousness would demand.
Why HN recommends it
Pointed to as a clear, balanced overview of quantum-brain theories when AI consciousness and brain models come up.
check especially the ending summary where they calculate more or less how much would be necessary — HN, 2024
Quantum physics · Consciousness & cognition
Subtitles (excerpt)
Hey Everyone. We have some fun new merch at the merch store, we’ll let you know more at the end of the episode. Nobel laureate Roger Penrose is widely held to be one of the most brilliant living physicists for his wide-ranging work from black holes to cosmology. And then there’s his idea about how consciousness is caused by quantum processes. Most scientists have dismissed this as a cute eccentricity—a guy like Roger gets to have at least one crazy theory without being demoted from the supersmartypants club. The most common argument for this dismissal is that quantum effects can’t survive long enough in an environment as warm and chaotic as the brain. Well, a new study has revealed that Penrose’s prime candidate molecule for this quantum activity does indeed exhibit large scale quantum activity. So was Penrose right after all? Are you a quantum entity? The story starts with Roger Penrose as a young man attending a lecture on the Gödel incompleteness theorems. These are the mathematical arguments by logician Kurt Gödel, which prove the limits of proof. The first incompleteness theorem says that, for any consistent formal mathematical system capable of expressing basic arithmetic, there are true statements in that system that
On Hacker News
there is a theory by the brilliant Roger Penrose and extended by others that the brain is just not neurons but also quantum effect which would make it impossible to emulate via current technology excellent PBS Space Time on that * [VIDEO] — ck2, 2026-08
There's a few videos by Sabine/Anton and also now PBS about Microtubules and conciousness, it's starting to gain ground and If I were an AI company right now I'd be having cold sweat. Video of reference (check especially the ending summary where they calculate more or less how much would be necessary just to replicate a human mind's way of achieving conciousness if microtubules in fact contribute… — dev1ycan, 2024-08
sociopaths sometimes study people to learn how to emulate emotion that's exactly the state of "AI" right now, it's cold, mathematical emulation btw there are some fascinating papers on the concept that consciousness in humans is actually a quantum effect brilliant Roger Penrose proposed it (and they thought he was nuts) but recent discoveries about microtubules make it plausible so who knows, may… — ck2, 2026-06
I have completed an interview with a neurosurgeon recently. I'm writing an article for a big magazine about AI and Brains, and I was given a chance to get some comments from a neurosurgeon about AI, thinkingness and how he things things work. I can't disclose the contents of the interview, this is under NDA till published. But, gosh, was that bad. I thought neurosurgeon would know something about… — IFC_LLC, 2025-09
I gave you an example, qualia. I gave you another example, the philosophical zombie problem. The latter has real implications, how can we know whether or not a coma patient is conscious? There's new evidence to support the idea of quantum effects in the brain. Far from conclusive, but it does give a little credibility to the idea. [VIDEO] There's also a hypothesis that the electromagnetic field p… — poikroequ, 2024-08
Related videos
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- George Lakoff: Moral Politics · University of California Television (UCTV) · 58:57
- What Bodies Think About: Bioelectric Computation Outside the Nervous System - NeurIPS 2018 · The Artificial Intelligence Channel · 52:06
- Quantum Entanglement & Spooky Action at a Distance · Veritasium · 9:15
- Analogy as the Core of Cognition · Stanford · 1:08:37
- The Egg - A Short Story · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 8:06
- Ep. 1 - Awakening from the Meaning Crisis - Introduction · John Vervaeke’s Lectern · 59:16
- You Actually Share Your Brain With a Silent Stranger · CGP Grey · 4:57
- Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of the Universe - with David Tong · The Royal Institution · 1:00:17
- The Physics and Philosophy of Time - with Carlo Rovelli · The Royal Institution · 54:54
- Debate Noam Chomsky & Michel Foucault - On human nature [Subtitled] · withDefiance · 1:10:03
- The Biggest Ideas in the Universe: Introduction · Sean Carroll · 6:33
- Demystifying the Higgs Boson with Leonard Susskind · Stanford · 1:15:08
- Joscha Bach: Artificial Consciousness and the Nature of Reality | Lex Fridman Podcast #101 · Lex Fridman · 3:00:18
- The more general uncertainty principle, regarding Fourier transforms · 3Blue1Brown · 18:06
- Visualization of Quantum Physics (Quantum Mechanics) · udiprod · 14:33