The Wire: Fix The Crime Statistics...or...

Channel:bttp011 · Length:1:30 · Published:2011-02-21 · Views:140473

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A two-minute scene from The Wire in which Baltimore police brass pressure subordinates to fix the crime statistics. It dramatizes how metrics and incentives distort policing.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a shorthand illustration of juking the stats and Goodhart-style metric gaming.

Here is a great scene talking about metrics/stats from The Wire — HN, 2015

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Law, policing & justice · Film & TV clips

Subtitles (excerpt)

Gentlemen, the word from on high is that felony rates district by district will decline by 5% before the end of the year. We are dealing in certainties. You will reduce the UCR felonies by 5% or more. Or, and I've always wanted to say this. Let no man come back alive. In addition, we will hold this year's murders to 275 or less. Christ. Feeling a little phased, Colonel Foster. A little dispic who? No, sir. I'm good to go. Here's a fun fact for you people. If Baltimore had New York's population, we'd be clocking 4,000 murders a year at this rate. There is no excuse I will accept. I don't care how you do it. Just [ __ ] do it. Uh deputy, as uh familiar as we all are with the urban crime environment, uh I think we all understand there are certain um uh processes by which you can uh reduce the number of overall felonies. You can reclassify a nag assault or you can unfound a robbery. But uh how do you make a body disappear? There isn't one of you in this room who isn't here by appointment. If you want to continue wearing those oak clusters, you will shut up and step up. Any of you who can't bring in the numbers we need will be replaced by someone who can. That is all.

On Hacker News

> Now watch governments do the same. They've already been doing that for ages: crime rate, gdp, employment, inflation. Here is a clip from my favourite show that highlights this: [VIDEO] — creakingstairs, 2022-02
> No, they generally do the latter, and generally well. Minor quibble, but I don't find a 50% clearance rate on murders to be good. [0] I also don't put much faith in the accuracy of many (most) police departments numbers as they "Juke the Stats" [1] [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — FullMtlAlcoholc, 2016-11
David Simon is a national treasure. The Wire had lots of scenes on how metrics & incentives screwed up Baltimore city. Here is a great scene talking about metrics/stats from The Wire - [VIDEO] Article also refers to Martin Malley's ambition to be Maryland's governor that really screwed up the incentives and cooking of the books. "How do you reward cops? Two ways: promotion and cash. That's what r… — nrao123, 2015-04

Related videos