Germany: Low Crime, Clean Prisons, Lessons for America | Jeff Rosen | TEDxMountainViewHighSchool

Channel:TEDx Talks · Length:25:57 · Published:2017-01-30 · Views:3077034

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeff Rosen explains in a TEDx talk why Germany has lower crime and far fewer prisoners than the US, and what American criminal justice could learn from German prisons.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a comparison of German rehabilitative prisons with American retributive justice, backed by statistics.

the whole talk is rather worthwhile to watch — HN, 2020

Law, policing & justice · Social issues & culture

Subtitles (excerpt)

Translator: Leonardo Silva Reviewer: Peter van de Ven When I was growing up, my family didn't have a dog. Other kids in the neighborhood had a dog. So, one day I asked my dad, "Why don't we have a dog?" And my dad said, "Because they used 'Hunds' on us," meaning that the Nazis used dogs to attack and intimidate my family, my dad and my grandmother, during the three years that they spent in Nazi concentration camps. We also didn't have a German car - no Volkswagen, no Mercedes, no BMW. "Nazi cars" is what my dad called them. Last summer, I was standing at the Hertz rental car counter in Berlin when the clerk said to me, "Mr. Rosen, I'm very sorry, we don't have the car that you reserved," and my face kind of fell. And the clerk said, "But don't worry, Mr. Rosen. I have really good news for you. I've got a car that has a sunroof, and it's leather, and it's big; it's a wonderful luxury car. Mr. Rosen, let me show you the beautiful Mercedes-Benz that we have for you." And I thought, "This is going to be kind of an interesting road trip, where I'm going to be taking this car." I'll tell you where I took this car at the end of this talk. Let me first tell you why I went to Germany to begin with and what I learned there.

On Hacker News

On the topic of prison systems in America vs. the civilized world, this is absolutely worth a watch: [VIDEO] — Lev1a, 2022-08
Or this talk about one of Denmarks neighbours (Germany) by an American, Jewish, (grand-)son of Holocaust survivors visiting a German prison with a bunch of other Americans ("60 Minutes" reporter, some Governor, a DA, a convicted murderer etc.). A bunch of stats and comparisons to underline the effects of different prison systems: [VIDEO] And the related segment from "60 Minutes": [LINK] — Lev1a, 2021-05
It's debatable if the police state was actually responsible for that drop in crime. Afaik Canada saw a comparable drop in crime, over the same time-period, without starting to mass incarcerate people [0] [0] [VIDEO] (Relevant stats and discussion start around 6:45, but the whole talk is rather worthwhile to watch) — freeflight, 2020-12
I'd recommend to watch this talk about the German prison system from an American perspective. The main point is the difference between European resocialization and US retributive justice. Although this may show the bright sides here in Germany a little bit too bright, they do exist. [VIDEO] — okket, 2017-05
When you design for the "edge cases" you end up with a bunch of Supermaxes were people vegitate 23 hours a day in solitary, which is btw commonly considered torture [0] Maybe the goal shouldn't be to design for "unchecked edge cases to apply maximum punishment" but rather a fundamental change in US prison and incarceration policies [1] [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — freeflight, 2021-12

Related videos