Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In A Guitar Amplifier?

Channel:Jim Lill · Length:18:34 · Published:2022-10-03 · Views:843003

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Guitarist Jim Lill spends a year testing where guitar amplifier tone comes from, swapping tubes, rectifiers and bias types. He finds that much of it can be reproduced with EQ and distortion in different orders.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a systematic, surprising experiment, often cited in audio and gear-obsession threads.

check out this guy who ran a much more systematic set of experiments — HN, 2026

Audio & video engineering · Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

foreign I'm a musician in Nashville and I'm interested in learning where guitar tone comes from so this year I've done videos on the electric guitar sustained strings scale length and speaker cabinets which led to me figuring out which guitar cab was used on my favorite music and now I want to figure out where the tone comes from in a guitar amplifier electric guitars by themselves are pretty quiet but when plugged into an amp they get really loud and early on people realize the amps don't just make the guitar louder they change how the guitar sounds and different types of amps sound different from each other so what makes a marshall not sound like a Vox or a Vox not sound like a fender or even a 50s Tweed Fender not sound like a 60s black Fender why don't cheap amp sound like expensive amps or do they what about the amp is actually causing this to happen I have a pretty good idea of what affects the cab because of the big cab video I did and I'll get to testing out speakers in a future video so right now I'm mostly thinking about the amp circuitry the thing that makes this difficult is I'm just a performer I don't know anything about circuits but I can type questions into the internet and see what comes up and when I search

On Hacker News

I'm convinced that at least 90% of "analog sound" can be simulated by taking the ideal block diagram and replacing every link with a parametric EQ->waveshaper->parametric EQ chain. Configuring those added components correctly is left as an exercise for the reader. Jim Lill's video on guitar amp tone is an interesting demonstration. Hear how close he gets to the original with an even simpler combi… — mrob, 2026-03
If this is appealing to you, check out this guy who ran a much more systematic set of experiments on even more sacred and sensitive targets: Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In An Electric Guitar? [LINK] Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In A Guitar Amplifier? [VIDEO] — gadtfly, 2026-03
I'd like to plug the YouTube Video by Jim Lill - "Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In A Guitar Amplifier?" [VIDEO] — WorkerBee28474, 2025-11
Jim Lill has a video testing amp tone: [VIDEO] It's almost entirely EQ and distortion, applied in various orders (the exact signal chain matters, because EQ after distortion sounds different than distortion after EQ). By getting this right you can simulate any tube amp tone with solid state to a high degree of accuracy. — mrob, 2025-05
Love his series, but you really have to keep in mind that his testing methodology is "reductionist": a microphone's quality can't just be distilled to its EQ response. Phase, transient response, clipping, etc. are also part of the equation. edit: My "case in point" moment is Jim's (excellent!) DIY amp section in this video: [VIDEO] . Its EQ indeed sounds like the big names, but I'm sure you'll al… — leblancfg, 2025-01

Related videos