'Oumuamua Is Not Aliens

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:17:32 · Published:2018-11-21 · Views:790052

Watch on YouTube

Summary

PBS Space Time examines the interstellar object 'Oumuamua and the popular theories about it, including the light-sail hypothesis. It argues that a natural rock is the likeliest explanation.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a sober analysis of 'Oumuamua theories that counters the alien-spacecraft claims.

And I really recommend this PBS Space Time Video — HN, 2019

Cosmology & astrophysics · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

Thanks to Brilliant.org for supporting PBS Digital Studios. To repeat the Space Time maxim: It's never aliens... ... until it is! So, let's talk about 'Oumuamua. Last year, a visitor came to our inner Solar System. To us, it looked like a faint spot of light, moving quickly relative to the fixed stars. We'd seen similar things countless times before: lonely rocks, remnants of the formation of our Solar System, drifting on their endless orbits around the Sun, and faintly glimmering with its reflected light. Nothing unusual about such asteroids and comets, but what made this object special was its trajectory. It was not in orbit around the Sun at all. Rather, it appeared to have fallen in from interstellar space, and was on its way back out again. The object is 1I/2017 U1 -- better known as 'Oumuamua. It's the first chunk of interstellar space debris we've ever spotted passing through our Solar System. It caused a justifiable stir at the time -- hell, even we did an episode on it! But 'Oumuamua has been making the news again. This time, it's for a new paper by Schmuel Bialy and Avi Loeb that investigates the possibility that 'Oumuamua is... ... aliens! Or, more accurately, an artificial light

On Hacker News

And I really recommend this PBS Space Time Video: [VIDEO] He makes excellent points that given historical data, a mm thin solar sail really shouldn't be our first conclusion instead of a collection of rocks that broke apart and refused back together (think of a combination of Shoemaker-Levy and Ultima Thule). And given the short length of time we've been observing space, chances of one of the fir… — justaguyonline, 2019-02
The PBS Space Time video series, written and hosted by Lehman College astrophysicist Matthew O’Dowd, has a nice analysis of popular 'Oumuamua theories: "'Oumuamua Is Not Aliens" [VIDEO] — cpeterso, 2019-03
If you like videos, PBS Space Time published one recently about the paper that tests the light sail hypothesis: [VIDEO] — herogreen, 2018-11
For me it went into the opposite direction after listening to 'omuamua is not aliens' video [1]. I think Dr. Loeb, contrary to what he says, is exploiting this a bit for some personal gain and fame. [1]: [VIDEO] — kkoncevicius, 2021-02

Related videos