The LED's Challenge to High Pressure Sodium
Channel:Technology Connections · Length:21:39 · Published:2018-06-19 · Views:1641508
Summary
A Technology Connections video weighing LED streetlights against high pressure sodium lamps, covering efficiency, color, cost and light pollution. It is a follow-up to his earlier explanation of why street lights are orange.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters point to it in lighting threads for its pros and cons of LED versus sodium lamps, though one calls it almost right.
Here's a quite good video about the pros and cons of LED vs high/low-pressure sodium street lamps — HN, 2020
Everyday physics & science demos · Renewables, batteries & storage · Power grid, heating & buildings
Subtitles (excerpt)
In my last video, we talked about the high pressure sodium lamp and its ubiquitous use in outdoor lighting. Already this type of lighting is starting to be phased out with various technologies, with new LED technology among the most common. Now, given the robust nature of the sodium lamp and its proven track record in providing an efficient light source reliably, does it make sense that we switch to newer light sources? Well, as usual in life, there are pros and cons. So let’s start with a basic question: why do we use outdoor lighting? For street lighting, specifically, the basic answer is to improve safety, particularly pedestrian safety. The odds of a crash of any kind are greater at night, because it’s harder to see. With the aid of artificial roadway lighting, a driver can see much farther than their car’s headlights shine, especially to the sides. Now of course there are disadvantages to large amounts of street lighting, which we’ll get to, but assuming safety is the goal, are sodium lamps good? Well, no. Not really. Remember how I said that the Sodium D-line is close to our eyes’ peak sensitivity, but only under photopic daylight conditions? Well it turns out that our eyes see quite differently at night than during the day.
On Hacker News
Here's a quite good video about the pros and cons of LED vs high/low-pressure sodium street lamps: [VIDEO] . It goes into lamp efficiency, how our eyes see differently at night, response time under different sorts of light, color temperature, circadian rhythm disruption, and light pollution. — kibwen, 2020-08
The youtube channel Technology Connections has a couple of interesting articles about LED (and sodium-vapor lamp) bulbs in street lighting: [VIDEO] (Actually, most if his videos are pretty interesting to explore, especially the ones about early TV) — news_to_me, 2018-08
I'm reminded of a Technology Connections video about what happened when his town switched from incandescent to LED stop lights < [LINK] > Of course, while I was looking that up I found out he made a video about sodium vapour lights! < [VIDEO] > — jedimastert, 2021-03
Warm white LEDs exist, with color quality exceeding that of sodium vapor in every way, but cities often use blueish LEDs because they're cheaper and more efficient. Relevant Technology Connections video: [VIDEO] — p1mrx, 2019-05
It's a good video, but it's also a case study in being 'almost right'. The almost-correct interpretations cascade and result in a faulty conclusion: that blue-white LED streetlights are better than orange-white streetlights. Various comments object to the faulty conclusion ([1], for example). At the end he at least addresses his ignorance: > [18:39] You may have noticed that I didn't talk about t… — teslabox, 2020-08
Related videos
- The Epic Of Gilgamesh In Sumerian · Peter Pringle · 3:55
- NaN Gates and Flip FLOPS · suckerpinch · 19:07
- Mechanical Computer (All Parts) - Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers · Excelsior10000 · 41:53
- SNES Code Injection -- Flappy Bird in SMW · SethBling · 6:31
- Mars Helicopter (before it went to Mars) · Veritasium · 16:00
- RAT POISON AND BRANDY: THE 1904 ST. LOUIS OLYMPIC MARATHON. · Jon Bois · 21:02
- Was Roman Concrete Better? · Practical Engineering · 9:34
- TRUE Limits Of Humanity – The Final Border We Will Never Cross · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 11:40
- Thinking outside the 10-dimensional box · 3Blue1Brown · 25:13
- 1,000km Cable to the Stars - The Skyhook · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 7:00
- How a transistor works · Ben Eater · 11:23
- AT&T Archives: Similiarities of Wave Behavior (Bonus Edition) · AT&T Tech Channel · 28:02
- Heat Pumps: the Future of Home Heating · Technology Connections · 35:15
- James Burke Connections, Ep. 1 "The Trigger Effect" · DRS_Education · 49:22
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Václav Smil at Driva Climate Investment Meeting 2019 · Nysnø Klimainvesteringer · 52:10