Gell-Mann Amnesia and Michio Kaku

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:50:05 · Published:2023-06-18 · Views:482945

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Angela Collier uses Gell-Mann amnesia to critique pop-science figures, especially Michio Kaku, and works through an eigenvalue problem along the way. It is a long, rambling commentary on how experts see simplified explanations of their own field.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it for the Gell-Mann amnesia framing and as a skeptical take on Michio Kaku.

Dr Angela Collier has this fun concept she calls Mann-Gell Amnesia — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

so sometimes I talk about science communication and stuff this is that [Music] come on Amnesia as a concept was discussed by Michael Crichton the author of Jurassic Park and tons of other stuff he also directed the first Westworld movie from the 70s that's pretty cool he needs his mama oh briefly stated the Gelman Amnesia effect is as follows you open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well in Murray's case physics in mine Show Business you read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues often the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward reversing cause and effect I call these the wet streets cause rain stories papers full of them in any case you read with exasperation or Amusement the multiple errors in a story and then turn the page to National or International Affairs and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read you turn the page and forget what you know since I am a Scientist I know how articles about physics are written and how bad they are so I think I can just apply that to everywhere in my life but I find that I have a problem remembering my Gilman Amnesia

On Hacker News

Dr Angela Collier has this fun concept she calls Mann-Gell Amnesia about how basic explanations of topics you are an expert in always seem very unsatisfactory, even when they come from good sources. It's definitely a weird little bias I've noticed in myself! [VIDEO] — rozab, 2024-12
A couple paragraphs in and I’m already like “Ah, here comes the Michael Crichton quote, the “papers’ full of ‘em” one.” I’ve never read one of these that didn’t come off as unbearably smug. Like sure, discerning the truth is hard, duh. But the people who try their best to do it, even if they sometimes fail, are worth immeasurably more than the dead-souled people who decide “might as well sling bu… — Uehreka, 2024-06
Ah, yes. The "Igon Value Problem": [VIDEO] I was thinking the cautiousness was intentionally bred into LLMs, but it could very well be an artifact of the training data, too. — Leftium, 2026-07
A really useful meta-question is: How much work is it to answer that question? A few examples: Junior devs asking about how to do something - sometimes the answer is clear, there's a standard or a decision has already been made - sometimes someone has to do some work to decide how to proceed. Its easy for people to get frustrated when they think they asked a simple question, but at the point they… — csours, 2024-06
Angela Collier (a theoretical physicist) is also pretty harsh on him [1]. The main critique of him is that he happily keeps talking authoritatively and confidently about scientific topics that he has very little knowledge about (e.g., quantum computing). [1] [VIDEO] — DavidVoid, 2024-05

Related videos