Hold music used to sound better. Here's why.

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:3:36 · Published:2017-11-27 · Views:2932056

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott explains why hold music sounds worse than it used to, tracing it to old telephone exchanges and the audio compression applied by modern switches. It is a short visit to the Milton Keynes Museum.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it as the standard answer to why phone hold music sounds poor.

Tom Scott did a video on it.[0] It basically boils down to telephone switches starting to compress the audio. — HN, 2023

Information theory & signal processing · Audio & video engineering · History of computing

Subtitles (excerpt)

If you're on hold to a company, and they're playing music down the phone at you, the chances are it sounds terrible, and sometimes it just dissolves into static. Telephone signals are not designed to carry music, and to explain why, we have to start way, way back with old telephone equipment like this. Early telephone calls were put through by a human operator who would be literally connecting the two phone wires into one circuit at a big board of switches. Or a "switchboard". Any sound at one end, whether it's speech, music, whatever, would be converted to an electrical signal, sent down the wire, and converted back at the other end. You send music, you receive music -- although it'd be limited by the abilities of the tiny microphone and speaker. But telephone exchanges like this only work for small numbers of connections. Because, you know, you can't do this for every call. [PHONE RINGS] Phone companies quickly realised that they could save on setting up thousands of wires between exchanges miles apart if they were able to put several conversations down one wire at the same time. So rather than transmit every frequency of sound in the original signal, they would cut off the high and low frequencies,

On Hacker News

There's a legitimate reason for that. Tom Scott did a video on it.[0] It basically boils down to telephone switches starting to compress the audio. Compress and decompress multiple times (by various companies) on the way to you, and the quality degrades very quick. [0]: [VIDEO] — colejohnson66, 2023-07
Relevant Tom Scott's "Things You Might Not Know"-Video: "Why Hold Music Sounds Worse Now" - [VIDEO] — eliaspro, 2018-03
Doesn't most carriers heavily "compress" the sound, removing all sounds/frequencies that a human can't hear, etc? [VIDEO] — Svenskunganka, 2018-05

Related videos