ASTOUNDING: 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + ... = -1/12

Channel:Numberphile · Length:7:50 · Published:2014-01-09 · Views:9853037

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Numberphile video in which physicists Tony Padilla and Ed Copeland show a seemingly astounding result that 1+2+3+4+... equals -1/12. The argument is informal and has drawn criticism for glossing over what the result actually means.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the standard reference for the -1/12 meme, with commenters split between enjoying it and calling it a cheat.

Watch this entertaining Numberphile video about this topic — HN, 2014

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm gonna give you an astounding result Astounding? An astounding result So I'm just gonna write down a little sum I'm just gonna see what answer it gives. 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + duh duh duh duh duh And I include all the natural numbers, so all the way up to infinity So what do you reckon the answer to this is, Brady? -Well I would say it would go to tend towards infinity. Yeah, that makes sense, doesn't it. The answer to this sum is -- remarkably -- minus a twelfth. It's amazing! I mean, I first saw this result when I start learning a bit of String Theory And what's even more bizarre is that this result is used in many areas of physics This is a very well known string theory textbook by Joe Polchinski. As you can see, sort of quite early on, page 22, we have this statement here which is that the sum of all this is --- basically saying the sum of all the integers --- all natural numbers all the way up to infinity, is, minus a twelfth. Alright so we're going to prove now, Without getting our knickers in a twist with Riemann zeta functions, we gonna prove in quite simple way, why the sum of all the natural numbers is indeed minus a twelfth. So, to do that we're gonna do this in a number of steps.

On Hacker News

this infinite sum was featured in a numberphile video a few days ago with a entraining and simple "proof": [VIDEO] and a more advanced explanation & proof in the bonus-video: [LINK] you should definitely subscribe to numberphile ( [LINK] ) and their sister channel computerphile ( [LINK] ) on youtube :) — alternize, 2014-01
This is a good video explaining it: [VIDEO] Although it relies on a particular interpretation of the left side of the equation, it's used in some areas of physics. — barbs, 2021-10
Watch this entertaining Numberphile video about this topic: [VIDEO] Apparently it's used in many areas in Physics. — yelnatz, 2014-01
It's referencing a theorem from string theory, as discussed in this Numberphile video: [VIDEO] The catch is that this isn't valid in what we consider standard mathematics, and you can find many discussions of this online, but this one is fairly short and straightforward: [LINK] — 9000, 2021-01
Few days back I stumbled upon a video about Ramanujan [0] and the: 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 ..(to infinity) = -1/12.(Turns out the proof in the video is incorrect or at least not concise enough, because you can't do that with divergent series). So that got me curious and I wanted to understand what's going on. How can 1 + 2 .. etc equal to -1/12 and not infinity. So I went on small binge watching videos to … — jyriand, 2020-10

Related videos