The Problem with America’s Lab Mice and Why it Should Matter to You

Channel:JRE Clips · Length:18:07 · Published:2020-06-18 · Views:1292147

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A JRE clip in which Bret Weinstein explains his concern that most American lab mice descend from a single lab lineage. He argues this undermines how well mouse research translates to humans.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it when discussing mouse-study reliability and reproducibility.

Here's the actual segment (18 mins) — HN, 2020

Biology & biotechnology · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

the Joe Rogan experience I was a graduate student studying bats in I was in Michigan and I was interested in evolutionary trade-offs that's my signature thing and there was a very good piece of work from a guy new George Williams great evolutionary biologist about the evolution of senescence that is to say the process by which we grow feeble and inefficient with age but most people call aging and basically that's classic paper explained why it is that creatures like us get old and die and the answer was basically this that you have a genome that's complex it's full of genes but there aren't enough genes to have a gene for every trait that you have in fact they're a tiny fraction of the number of genes you would need to cover all of the various characteristics you have so genes always do multiple things and in the case when a gene does something that's very good for you when you're young at some cost when you're old selection tends to favor it because you may not live long enough to suffer the cost and so if you have the trait that makes you powerful when you're young and you've got some cost that you're gonna pay when you're old but you're not gonna live to get it it may be a freebie right so selection sees early life much more clearly than it

On Hacker News

He specifically mentions comments like yours are not helpful. This is the researcher fraud that is the problem in science that we are talking about, issues at hand are ignored or twisted so the paper mill can continue. The concept is all mice in the USA come from one laboratory and have a common attribute that's different from wild mice and European suppliers. And it's spelt out how in theory thi… — aaron695, 2020-07
You may also need to buy that mouse from a specific lab for the therapies to have reproducible effects. [1] [1] - [VIDEO] — LinuxBender, 2021-04
There have been a few interviews with Bret Weinstein on this topic as it pertains to lab mice. [1] [2] I am curious if this is in any way related and would there be similar concerns around how humans deal with senescent cells and cancer if Telomere are artificially lengthened. Out of curiosity, does anyone in this field have more information to add to Bret's interview that can explain technically… — LinuxBender, 2020-11
Ever since I watched Bret Weinstein explain the problem with using today's lab mice[1], I've been more cautious about any results involving mice and cancer. [1] [VIDEO] — k2xl, 2020-07

Related videos