Zero Mass Water -BUSTED!

Channel:Thunderf00t · Length:18:00 · Published:2018-05-25 · Views:1117996

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Thunderf00t argues that Zero Mass Water's solar-powered atmospheric water generator is essentially a dehumidifier with solar panels. He critiques its economics and physics, especially in arid places.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in threads on atmospheric water harvesting as the standard debunking of such startups.

Thunderf00t has debunked a bunch of other enterprises doing water from the air — HN, 2021

Startups & entrepreneurship · Everyday physics & science demos · Renewables, batteries & storage

Subtitles (excerpt)

this is zero mass water it's a water startup operating out of an old car dealership in Scottsdale Arizona is this the next level of drinking water guys I'm kind of thirsty come check this out my money so we're here with zero mass water that the company that invented solar panels apparently creates drinking water from thin air it's actually water vapor or moisture in the air how cool would it be if you could take that moisture and turn it into clean drinking water well I found a company here in Phoenix that claims that they can do exactly that what if you could produce clean drinking water right out of thin air and without using electricity that's what one Arizona based startup is trying to do using a combination of solar energy material science and data 0ms water the next level presented by Lauren good in conjunction with Intel so you know this is gonna be really well researched and I got so many requests to debunk this crap because you know it's gonna give water took places that have no water because of the fact that we can say okay yep there's Syrian refugee issues in northern Lebanon let's go there yep Maria hit Puerto Rico yep let's go there hey there's issues in Flint let's go there hey by the way you're buying what ought of water in Berkeley let's displace

On Hacker News

Like the startups which try to make solar systems to condense drinking water from the air. They demonstrate it in wet climates where the idea works but the solar panels don't because it's cloudy and cool. Those environments don't need drinking water because they are rainy. Then they try it in deserts where the water is needed and the solar panel bit works, but the whole thing doesn't work because… — jodrellblank, 2025-05
Check out Thunderf00t's videos cricising solar water collectors, e.g.: - [VIDEO] - Zero Mass Water: BUSTED! "Honestly, it drives me crazy how many people have reinvented the dehumidifier, put a solar panel on it, and the media has danced around like theyve just saved the world!" - [LINK] - Self-filling water bottle: BUSTED! " The fact that its thermodynamically impossible seem to stop 'science co… — jodrellblank, 2022-03
Wow, I was under the impression that atmospheric water harvesting (AWH) was extremely inefficient. I don't have any numbers but things like [1][2] seem to indicate that AWH is currently not very useful. The paper doesn't seem to (if I read it correctly) actually address this directly, instead it talks about how much energy is needed to extract water at different relative humidity levels and facto… — hansvs, 2021-10
Nope, there's no magic or free lunch. It depends heavily on local conditions which might not always be suitable. Thunderf00t has debunked a bunch of other enterprises doing water from the air: [VIDEO] [LINK] [LINK] [LINK] etc — imglorp, 2021-08
Zero Mass Water -BUSTED! [VIDEO] You can do your own research for the other solutions presented in the article. I find the idea of groundwater recharge interesting. We dump large amounts of water into the sea having used the Earth as a Atmospheric Water Harvester. We need to be keeping all that. — aaron695, 2020-08

Related videos