Gall--Peters Projection

Channel:UsefulClips · Length:3:59 · Published:2010-07-30 · Views:2493603

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip from The West Wing in which characters argue for the Gall-Peters map projection over Mercator. It dramatizes how standard maps distort the relative size of countries.

Why HN recommends it

It is the go-to link in any HN thread on map projections, usually posted as the obligatory West Wing reference.

one of the best ways to teach someone about how different our classic maps are from reality — HN, 2015

Data visualization & information design · Film & TV clips

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] Hi, I'm sorry. Oh, sorry to be late. Not a problem. I'm CJ Craig. Of course you are. I'm Dr. John Fow with Dr. Cynthia Sales and uh Professor Donald Huke. Huke. Huke. Okay. And you are the Organization of Ctographers for Social Equality. Well, we're we're from the OCSE. We have many members. How many? 4,300 dues paid members. What are the dues? $20 a year for the newsletter. Let's start. Wait, wait. I want to say this. This is Josh Lyman. Indeed, you are. Josh, this is Dr. Fow and Hi, News Merry Men. Yes. Should we begin? Yes. Plain and simple. Uh, we'd like President Bartlett to aggressively support legislation that would make it mandatory for every public school in America to teach geography using the Peters projection map instead of the traditional Merkar. Give me 200 bucks and it's done. Really? No. Why are we changing maps? Uh, because CJ, the Merkar projection has fostered European imperialist attitudes for centuries and created an ethnic bias against the third world. Really? The German cgrapher Merkar originally designed this map in 1569 as a navigational tool for European sailors. The map enlarges areas at the poles to create straight lines of constant bearing or geographic direction. So it makes it easier to cross an ocean.

On Hacker News

The West Wing clip on maps is still one of the best ways to teach someone about how different our classic maps are from reality: [VIDEO] — Amorymeltzer, 2015-11
Requisite West Wing scene[1] on the subject (which is probably always going to be my top YouTube search because it’s fantastic). [1]: [VIDEO] — eyelidlessness, 2020-11
I made an interactive WebGL implementation of this without realizing it was a thing: [LINK] I don't really agree with the claims in the articles linked in OP, and don't find it to be a generally useful projection, even for the tool I made using it. It was novel as a representation that included daylight context (instead of just "what time is it there?" it helped express "is it getting dark there?… — brianshaler, 2024-04
I'd like to think you're being ironic here, but I suspect you're not, so no: the vast majority of the world is outside the US and has not, in fact, seen an obscure episode of a TV drama about American politics. For others who haven't, here it is: [VIDEO] Although the projection it proclaims as superior, Gall-Peters, has grievous flaws of its own. [LINK] — resolutebat, 2023-06
obligatory link to West Wing scene where they point out the political implications of the mercator projection [VIDEO] — greggman3, 2021-12

Related videos