We Need to Rethink Exercise (Updated Version)

Channel:Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · Length:13:07 · Published:2024-09-12 · Views:5962289

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Kurzgesagt explains why exercise alone does little for weight loss, since the body compensates by adjusting its total energy expenditure. It argues exercise is still very valuable for health.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a sourced, accessible summary in weight-loss and GLP-1 threads.

Kurzgesagt has a decent pop-science summary — HN, 2024

Nutrition & diet science · Fitness, sleep & longevity

Subtitles (excerpt)

Losing weight is hard and unfortunately, your body is sabotaging you every step of the way. Your body is a biological machine that follows the laws of thermodynamics and needs energy and raw materials to stay alive, which is why you eat. The energy from food is measured in calories and you need a certain amount to power your internal machines. Your brain thinks, your heart pumps, your gut digests, your immune system immuns. And you contract your muscles to move around. The harder a movement is, the more calories you burn. An hour of walking burns about 260 calories, moderate swimming 430, biking 600, running 700. If you eat more calories than you burn, your body stores them mostly in the form of fat. One kilogram, or two pounds of fat is about 7000 calories. Seems simple. To lose weight, you have to burn more than you eat, so fat is turned back into energy. There are two ways to do this: Eating less – which we will cover in another video – and burning more, say by moving around aimlessly, also called working out. We also get told early on that exercising is healthy somehow, so working out should kill two birds with one stone. Unfortunately this doesn’t exactly work out. It is one of these frustrating experiences

On Hacker News

Like much of life it's more complicated than simple rules. It works for some people, but does not for everyone. As someone that has struggled with diet for the last decade or so these drugs have been a life saver. I've been able to eat healthy and feel full instead of being stuck in a cycle of eating right for a while and then eventually breaking under load. I've been able to have a consistency i… — mwmisner, 2024-10
Just doing more exercise doesn't actually help much with losing weight, as it turns out. The human body will optimize around even intense exercise to reduce calorie burn to a homeostatically stable level. The exercise will still make you healthier (and have some marginal extra calorie burn from e.g. extra muscle mass), but you'll only lose serious weight if you also reduce what you eat. There are… — crooked-v, 2024-10
This video goes over how it’s not really that simple. Ultimately your body will cancel that deficit out [VIDEO] — jakereps, 2025-01
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell : We Need to Rethink Exercise (Updated Version) - [VIDEO] Their videos have a section where they link the sources. In this case [LINK] — shagie, 2024-10
Apparently it's not exercise! [0] Yes exercise is very healthy, that has been proven, but loosing weight is mostly a matter of eating less, at least according to this (reputable) meta source. Apparently, over eating but not getting fat (which holds true for me), leads to other problems (also true for me, I have an autoimmune disorder). Eat less to lose weight. Exercise more to be healthy. (nice, … — teekert, 2024-09

Related videos